1 |
"Bob Young" <BYoung@××××××××××.com> posted |
2 |
FAEEIJPAOFEMBBLKPMJEGEIDHKAA.BYoung@××××××××××.com, excerpted below, on |
3 |
Thu, 28 Sep 2006 19:55:31 -0700: |
4 |
|
5 |
> Now we're getting off in to other discussions, companies purchase the CSS |
6 |
> IP of other companies all the time, such developement "polination" is |
7 |
> certaintly not dependent on OSS. This particular discussion however, was |
8 |
> about "slaveryware" vs "freedomware" from the viewpoint of the end user, |
9 |
> not corporations. To the vast majority of end users, OSS, while a nice |
10 |
> "feel good" thing, doesn't actually make them any more free in any real |
11 |
> practical way. |
12 |
|
13 |
Well, when a fair segment of end users /are/ corporations, and they are |
14 |
the ones funding the development and responsible for the fact that it's |
15 |
not just a hobby for many any more... I'd say excluding them from the |
16 |
picture is itself unrealistic. In fact, there are many disturbed by that |
17 |
trend, and I see their point, but find the trend an inevitable result of |
18 |
the mass popularization of what was once the few-hour-a-week-at-best hobby |
19 |
of a handful of very geeky developers. |
20 |
|
21 |
Another analogy can be made to voting. Even the majority of folks |
22 |
choosing to sit out a vote, many who may never have registered to vote at |
23 |
all and don't really intend to, would have serious problems with a |
24 |
suggestion that this right/freedom they have been choosing not to exercise |
25 |
be taken away. Just because you don't exercise it doesn't mean it's not a |
26 |
freedom. |
27 |
|
28 |
There's another aspect as well. Thomas Jefferson is quoted as saying "The |
29 |
tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of |
30 |
patriots and tyrants." (I recognize the name may not mean much to an |
31 |
international audience, but those who wish to can of course look it up, |
32 |
now that it's cited.) While one hopes this particular liberty won't come |
33 |
to that literally, there was a time a few years ago when I thought those |
34 |
who refused to surrender such freedoms of the mind might end up imprisoned |
35 |
-- and it could still happen, particularly in the areas of the arts as |
36 |
opposed to computer sciences, where we have a head start. After a bit of |
37 |
self-examination, I realized I couldn't honestly say I was committed to |
38 |
death, tho I believe in the freedom strongly enough that I /believe/ one |
39 |
/should/ be that committed. However, the reality is that some have |
40 |
already been imprisoned over it -- even reaching across other nations' |
41 |
laws to do it (xref Dmitry Sklyarov). I realized that those believing |
42 |
must certainly be prepared for that possibility, and that I felt it a |
43 |
tradeoff worth the cost. |
44 |
|
45 |
OTOH, it's foolish to needlessly tempt the legal fates, thus my insistence |
46 |
that I literally /cannot/ at this point legally run most unfree software, |
47 |
due to the EULAs, and therefore that I /will/ not do so. For someone |
48 |
considering the possibility of that level of sacrifice, telling that |
49 |
friend mentioned earlier that I cannot legally view his clip in the format |
50 |
it's currently in, merely foregoing that tiny bit of convenience while |
51 |
creating a slightly awkward situation, is a foregone conclusion. (I may |
52 |
also observe that likely fortunately for me, I don't have the technical |
53 |
skills to do the sort of reverse engineering that would be most likely to |
54 |
get one in the most serious legal straits, so realistically, the chances |
55 |
of it ever going beyond a trifling bit of inconvenience and perhaps a |
56 |
takedown order for being part of a whack-a-mole game similar to the DeCSS |
57 |
thing aren't as high as they'd be for a good coder and reverse engineer |
58 |
with similar beliefs.) |
59 |
|
60 |
Yes, that /does/ make me a radical to many, I realize that. However, |
61 |
that's the degree to which I hold the beliefs of slaveryware vs |
62 |
freedomware, and why it's /going/ to come up from time to time in my |
63 |
posts, as it's a rather large part of my world-view. The only other |
64 |
alternative would be to stop posting to whatever public forum (in the |
65 |
generic/broad sense, so mailing list included) entirely. |
66 |
|
67 |
-- |
68 |
Duncan - List replies preferred. No HTML msgs. |
69 |
"Every nonfree program has a lord, a master -- |
70 |
and if you use the program, he is your master." Richard Stallman |
71 |
|
72 |
-- |
73 |
gentoo-amd64@g.o mailing list |