List Archive: gentoo-dev
Note: Due to technical difficulties, the Archives are currently not up to date.
provides an alternative service for most mailing lists.c.f. bug 424647
It looks like the decision on whether or not to stop reply-to munging has
fallen to me. After a little debate, I have decided to leave the mailing
lists as they are.
First, I would ask that everyone read the excellent articles at the
They pretty well cover the pros & cons of reply-to munging. I find the
latter article much more compelling, but maybe that is b/c I like the
system how it is already. I would like to add one more point. I personally
do not use the "group reply" function on MUA's unless I really need to. I
don't want to even risk getting into the habit of hitting that and
accidentally mass-mailing a personal mail. You might notice that this is
very similar to an argument made in the first article above. My response
is that it is very unlikely that I will be mailing information of a
personal nature in response to a mailing list posting.
For those that want people to use a different address than their From:
address, I suggest you put it in your signature.
Feel free to respond to this, and if I feel that an overwhelming number of
you really would prefer to do away with Reply-to munging, then I will do it.
One other thing that I will consider. If a particular mailing list feels
that reply-to munging is not necessarily, we could remove it just for that
Chad Huneycutt (firstname.lastname@example.org)