Gentoo Archives: gentoo-doc

From: Maurits Lamers <maurits@×××××××××××××××.nl>
To: gentoo-doc@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-doc] Re: Gentoo Handbook versus x86 Quick Install Guide
Date: Fri, 14 Jul 2006 08:45:27
Message-Id: 6A4F69F8-36A7-4AF0-9DCD-5FDE5E62F25D@student-kmt.hku.nl
In Reply to: [gentoo-doc] Re: Gentoo Handbook versus x86 Quick Install Guide by Marc Blumentritt
1 Hi,
2
3 I think things are quite quiet here at the moment. Holyday times etc :)
4 It is possible that they haven't read it yet :)
5
6 regards
7
8 Maurits
9
10 Op 14-jul-2006, om 10:31 heeft Marc Blumentritt het volgende geschreven:
11
12 > Hi,
13 >
14 > Marc Blumentritt schrieb:
15 >>
16 >> Any thoughts about this?
17 >> I think, both (handbook and guide) should be made consistent with
18 >> each
19 >> other, with the handbook including some more informations about
20 >> why you
21 >> should do this and that.
22 >>
23 >
24 > one week and no answer, so perhaps I did something wrong? If I
25 > offended
26 > in my post anyone, than sorry, I did not intend this in any way.
27 >
28 > On the other hand, if you all think, that it is just not worth to
29 > answer
30 > to my post, because of the insignificant content of it, I try to
31 > convince you that this is not the case ;-)
32 >
33 > Ok, why did I post about these differences in Handbook and Quick
34 > Installer?
35 >
36 > I'm using Gentoo since Release 2005.0 and it was the documentation and
37 > the step-by-step installation, which pushed me over to Gentoo. Why?
38 > Because I wanted to learn more about how Linux is working and with
39 > Gentoo I could (and still can) learn a lot! Before Gentoo I never
40 > compiled anything before. I did not know anything about this
41 > mysterious
42 > Toolchain and gcc. OK, I knew, that a compiler was creating binaries
43 > from source code, but that's all. This changed by working with
44 > Gentoo. I
45 > was one of the guys, who happily broke thier system with the gcc-3.4
46 > upgrade (because I missed the upgrade guide). After resurrecting my
47 > system, I decided to learn more about this Toolchain. I stumbled
48 > over a
49 > lot of posts on the Forums, which were promoting "emerge -e system &&
50 > emerge -e system && emerge -e world && emerge -e world" or
51 > "emerge-wrappers" scripts for upgrading your system after changes
52 > of the
53 > toolchain. For some time I believed, this was the way to go. But
54 > recently I read in different places about opposing opinions, so I
55 > again
56 > started to look for some official Gentoo guides containing anything
57 > about this topic. This was the first time I read the Qick Install
58 > Guide
59 > and I was surprised, that it stated more small informations than the
60 > Handbook.
61 >
62 > So here comes the answer to my own question: I wrote my post,
63 > because I
64 > think, the handbook should contain every Informationen about
65 > installing
66 > and maintaining yor Gentoo system. And this should be done with some
67 > background explanations. The handbook is already great (really, thank
68 > you all for this great guide), but the Quick Install guide contains
69 > more
70 > informations about two topics (changing compile options and upgrading
71 > your system), which are crucial. I wrote about this in my first post
72 > without all my background thoughts you just (hopefully) read,
73 > because I
74 > did not want to bore you with them, so I will stop right now!
75 >
76 > Thanks for reading and any comments are welcome (I hope, there are
77 > some).
78 > Regards,
79 > Marc
80 >
81 >
82 > P.S.: I'm still looking for more informations about toolchain handling
83 > in Gentoo...
84 > --
85 > gentoo-doc@g.o mailing list
86 >
87
88 --
89 gentoo-doc@g.o mailing list

Replies

Subject Author
[gentoo-doc] Re: Gentoo Handbook versus x86 Quick Install Guide Marc Blumentritt <M.Blumentritt@×××××××××××××××.de>