List Archive: gentoo-osx
Note: Due to technical difficulties, the Archives are currently not up to date.
provides an alternative service for most mailing lists.c.f. bug 424647
as you all might know, readline is not existant on your OSX box. At
least it looks like that. Apple supplies libedit and by default
symlinks it to readline in /usr/lib thereby triggering our collision
protect when emerging readline:
% la /usr/lib/libreadline.dylib
lrwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 13 Aug 20 14:17 /usr/lib/libreadline.dylib
Not very interesting are this link and the libedit library, as they
don't seem to care to link some readline.h file in
/usr/include/readline/readline.h too. So far, no big news I guess.
% locate readline.h
This output looked very interesting, and scanning the readline.h file in
MacOSX10.4u.sdk it gave me the impression that this was dealing with
an up-to-date version of libedit: one that has a compatibility layer
with readline. At least the rl_* functions are declared out there. So
I stepped into those shoes and decided to patch up libxml to use
readline from /Developer/SDKs/MacOSX10.4u.sdk/. Well, ok, because the
configure script seems to plainly ignore whatever you tell it I just
compiled the single file that failed due to a readline dep by hand, and
it was a success, that is after that running make again, everything
finished happily to compile. "make check" was pretty happy too. Running:
% ./.libs/tester --shell test/slashdot.xml
even gave me an editable prompt with history (!).
Moral of the story: GNU is not Linux. Ehm, no.
- libedit appears to be a 'good enough' replacement for some tools, good
enough to make >=readline-4.1 applications compile
- libedit is in portage
- libedit is supplied with OSX
- libedit is even completer (with readline.h) supplied with Apple's SDKs.
- there unfortunately is no virtual/readline in town, so emerging
libedit doesn't give you readline, while in fact it does.
- assumming we would just lie some more to portage about what it has and
what it doesn't have, we would have to add the readline.h file to
/usr/include and make a package.provided.
I think all is dirty, but not being able to compile libxml because the
testing program -- which a regular user will never use -- uses readline
for its --shell mode which it doesn't even use in make check stinks too.
Besides that I'd like to go a bit broader here for a sec. GPL is
considered to be a virus by many people, and shouldn't this
virtual/readline be a part of portage instead of assuming you use GNU's
Feel free to tell me I should just wait till we can simply install
readline. (then still I'd like to use libedit I think)
eBuild && Porting
Gentoo for Mac OS X
firstname.lastname@example.org mailing list