It should be rather obvious by now that I don't think we need the 
proctors. 

Nevertheless, some points made below need to be addressed.

On Sunday, June 10, 2007 10:16:09 AM Ranjit Singh wrote:

> > Do we want/accept penalties/remedies crossing mediums? (Do we want a
> > ban from forums to extend to bugzilla?)
> Yes.

No. If the offender does behave on other mediums, why should he be banned 
from those?

> > Do we want/accept permanent bans?
> Yes.

No! Everyone deserves another chance.

> > What audience?
> > Do we address users and devs? (council said everyone)
> ++

For devs we have DevRel.

> > What powers can/will the proctors have over devs?
> What? As above.

None.

> > Do proctors act on devs directly or through devrel?
> Directly with input from kloeri and g2boojum

For obvious reasons (kloeri retired), there should be no personal 
involvement but groups only.

> > Are proctors elected or appointed and by whom?
> Elected from pool: forum admins, devrel and council.

Elected. From the developer community.

> > Who controls the proctors? (who watches the watchman?)
> Er we do. Got it? :)

The council and the developer community as they can vote for someone else 
for the next term.

> Flame on paludis minions!

Would you kindly leave this out of here? Thanks!

Best regards, Wulf