List Archive: gentoo-qa
Note: Due to technical difficulties, the Archives are currently not up to date.
provides an alternative service for most mailing lists.c.f. bug 424647
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Mark Loeser wrote:
> This is the exact problem I'm trying to address. You'll never get all
> of the projects to agree, since they all want to go in slightly
> different directions and do different things. All three are great
> ideas, but we should only support the one that is official for Gentoo,
> and not make any changes to the tree. (Note: changes here is any
> modification or addition of files in the tree for the sole purpose of
> working with an alternate package manager)
I don't see any reason to include support for a non-official package manager in the official gentoo repo either (given that they can host their own repository and include whatever they want). For the sake of interoperability, I hope that the developers of these separate package managers can come together and agree on some specifications, but that's a topic for another list...
> Either way, I think this is something we should hold off on for now, and
> have the council decide upon. We shouldn't just make these changes
> without having some discussion taking place (the flamewar on g-dev@ is
> not a discussion, and is only a small minority of people giving their
> two cents).
> Whatever the decision is, the addition of another package manager makes
> QA harder to do since we have to consider all of them. Adding a new
> package manager and saying we don't support it, nor are we sure if we
> will ever support it, does not seem acceptable at all to me. The
> decision should be made if we plan on supporting it so we can work on
> actually supporting it, or if this should be a completely separate
> project and they can work on their own to make changes to ebuilds which
> support their own functionality.
Yeah, it seems like this type of decision needs to be made by the council, and I hope that they decide against it.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.3 (GNU/Linux)
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
email@example.com mailing list