Gentoo Archives: gentoo-security

From: Alec Warner <warnera6@×××××××.edu>
To: gentoo-security@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-security] Kernels and GLSAs
Date: Wed, 21 Sep 2005 04:23:34
Message-Id: 4330DF1D.6000502@egr.msu.edu
In Reply to: Re: [gentoo-security] Kernels and GLSAs by Thierry Carrez
1 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
2 Hash: SHA1
3
4 Thierry Carrez wrote:
5 > Brian G. Peterson wrote:
6 >
7 >
8 >>On Tuesday 20 September 2005 06:09 am, Calum wrote:
9 >>
10 >>
11 > This ongoing kernel security information, along with kernel security
12 > alerts when really big things are discovered (Local Root that would work
13 > on most configurations, for example) was for us the best solution. KISS
14 > is almost ready for BETA release, meaning you should be able to access
15 > it very soon for testing.
16 >
17 > Also KISS was no secret, it's in the Security project objectives for
18 > year 2005, as published on this list at the beginning of the year.
19 >
20 > Thanks for your attention.
21 >
22 <snip snip>
23
24 I am in support of whatever you decide, but I would expect there to be
25 documentation somewhere stating current policy ( that being that kernel
26 security bugs are not made into GLSA's ). Knowing this I can work
27 around it and find other ways to keep my kernel updated. However no one
28 wants to be under the false pretense that GLSA's cover all security
29 problems and then get nailed by a kernel security issue.
30
31 I don't see anything about the security seciton of gentoo's website
32 detailing that kernel security issues aren't in GLSA's and I think it
33 would be helpful to include that. It may even be helpful to add it to
34 the post_inst of gentoolkit/glsa-check's manpage. Right now if I read
35 the security handbook or the GLSA documentation I am misinformed.
36
37 If you are indeed switching to a system that works better I think many
38 would enjoy an upgrade of docs, or issuing GLSA's until you have KISS
39 running, or just documentation that says kernel security bugs are not
40 covered by GLSA's.
41
42 If you want a bug filed, I can do that as well.
43 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
44 Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux)
45 Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://enigmail.mozdev.org
46
47 iQIVAwUBQzDfHGzglR5RwbyYAQL5+w/+LTaohDpFWqguv98wkMXEl+ZwsQZNeSJt
48 WOV+X9HAqa+l/dvU0noCd0CvjKBCiYsmbzXHBiGvAmu3HYrdUGCejSC9pnVLRLlC
49 JkNRklehGGEzKBXNgPYrMnlq0ybF8UjFcTgkXIycG9ucJbCwD0hyotwRI1kGe3sM
50 Tuq1TqBjeZGNPfCymREqv6Pn9OlDWNVzXSQ9xnin0/xscVvQbUw8dAx4AgoTL4Jo
51 ltzNU89KMyeEALgy4W0ctE4v/tIbrPY+Ye/Ypd8AYO6JW5LBnik2njc3KArybzsp
52 2BOhBKMPC4mh3BLr2IP3kJzavtEOjvME/9DkqSuuDB09SexaGmiZSnCFkRG5XSs7
53 GQPVzsFxfW2c913FZ0I4Nij3jwK7PcGxOCUHhAirLd1VHizoFYBcHJxK1ldACUR0
54 dtSuc/2yAg1bMBkHvJhDS4MDEdIchqmvBsCD9YxjpZ+vulMdUDigP1jokiuqlLRp
55 y2rBGXfFJxCVywjvmJ67V45Rxh83QG75TaIP7LAb19pJH71lVbt1RqmvikIZuFHv
56 Te5cJ6HW5egWrjIMLKCp9ZpZrXpRCZXHxVoNwqUcI1QI+uTbKuBh/4DLsKFPjAvU
57 hWgvuIOxIaH3E2fHNoaaUbO90qeq8pmRFkUNHAc3TPIA6zcYwS/mne8PvFvq12rJ
58 8TPPR7XO2L0=
59 =hxQ6
60 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
61 --
62 gentoo-security@g.o mailing list