List Archive: gentoo-security
Note: Due to technical difficulties, the Archives are currently not up to date.
provides an alternative service for most mailing lists.c.f. bug 424647
On Saturday, 17. May 2008, Peter Schneider-Kamp wrote:
> the recently publicized SSL weak key generation for debian-based systems
> (c.f. http://www.debian.org/security/key-rollover/)
> has lead our university computing center to retract our
> Gentoo-generated SSL keys based on an advisory from the German
> DFN cert :-(
I could not find where these advisories are published on their site, I
guess they are not publicly distributed.
> I have not found any information about whether this might also
> affect Gentoo systems. A test with the Perl script from
> does not show vulnerability:
> ~ summary: keys found: 2, weak keys: 0
> So I guess that Gentoo-generated keys are not affected.
> Still it would be nice to have an official statement
> to prevent official certification bodies from retracting
> valid Gentoo-generated keys.
The Gentoo Security Team internally reviewed patches to
our "dev-libs/openssl" package right when we heard about the issue via a
private channel. We could confirm that the patch is not included in our
distribution. Furthermore, additional tests showed that there is no
dependence only on PID when generating keys, and that some Gentoo produced
keys are not included in the blacklist (which you also confirmed).
We issued no formal statement*, because Debian was so clear about the scope
of the vulnerability. To think that any distribution is affected, simply
because they do not publicly state they are not, is a bad habit. Other
CERTs usually contact us for vendor statements when they think we are
affected by one vulnerability.
The only thing compromising DSA keys generated on Gentoo is the usage of
the private key on an affected Debian, but even that was covered in both
the Debian and Ubuntu advisories.
Robert // Gentoo Security
* I would not consider my blog entry on http://planet.gentoo.org a
signature.asc (This is a digitally signed message part.)