Gentoo Archives: gentoo-security

From: Paul de Vrieze <pauldv@g.o>
To: gentoo-security@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-security] The solution and hopefully the end.
Date: Thu, 11 Nov 2004 10:57:16
Message-Id: 200411111156.49996.pauldv@gentoo.org
In Reply to: [gentoo-security] The solution and hopefully the end. by Kurt Lieber
1 On Wednesday 10 November 2004 14:52, Kurt Lieber wrote:
2 > Anyway, enough preaching. This thread has gone on long enough. The
3 > solution that's been agreeed upon is signing the daily snapshots that
4 > we provide for users who can't use rsync. (/snapshots directory on
5 > your favorite source mirror)
6
7 All right, repeating it is not usefull.
8
9 >
10 > This provides the ability to verify the integrity of every single file
11 > under /usr/portage/ and requires very little changes to our existing
12 > infrastructure. emerge-webrsync will be hacked up to provide
13 > verification support for it. I don't have any commitments from the
14 > portage devs that these changes will be included (emerge-webrsync is
15 > part of portage) so this may end up being an unsupported,
16 > use-at-your-own-risk solution. It does not take away from or alter the
17 > plans to implement a much better, more robust verification solution in
18 > portage itself.
19
20 Well, finally some useable solution. I'm fairly confident that the portage
21 devs will support it. I think it can be an acceptable measure until the
22 final measures are finalized.
23
24 Paul
25
26 > P.S. I do not want anyone to think that this solution is being
27 > implemented because of the bitching and screaming that occurred. If
28 > someone had posted a message to the list before all this broke out
29 > suggesting this solution and volunteering to write the code for it, it
30 > would be in place by now. That's another way of saying that we didn't
31 > have to go through all this unpleasantness...
32
33 ps. I'm fairly confident that all the bashing has in general been
34 counterproductive. I certainly have still about 100 mails on the mailing
35 list laying about, which I don't intend to read. I don't care much about
36 flamewars, and might certainly have missed productive suggestions.
37
38 At least now there is a good temporary measure, and we can now focus on
39 how the keychain maintenance can be handled (for the final solution)
40
41 --
42 Paul de Vrieze
43 Gentoo Developer
44 Mail: pauldv@g.o
45 Homepage: http://www.devrieze.net