Gentoo Archives: gentoo-trustees

From: drobbins <drobbins@g.o>
To: gentoo-trustees@l.g.o
Subject: RE: [gentoo-trustees] store and foundation..
Date: Sat, 20 Nov 2004 17:18:29
Message-Id: 200411201718.iAKHILar087519@taka.swcp.com
In Reply to: Re: [gentoo-trustees] store and foundation.. by Corey Shields
1 > I don't buy into the idea that someone else has caused you to feel like
2 > you can not be open with the Foundation, especially when you've been
3 > working through that person inpaticular for the most part. I haven't
4 > seen anything from you or heard from you in private, if there has been a
5 > problem that you feel was stopping you from being open with us, you
6 > could have made the effort to either let us know or work around that
7 > person. I'm not making excuses for Kurt here, but the claim that you
8 > make of him having a conflict of interest in this situation is offensive
9 > to me as I know Kurt, so I can't imagine how he must feel about it. If
10 > there really is something along those lines, you need to spell it out
11 > right now instead of going around causing rumors about that. Remember,
12 > "OPEN" communication here, please.
13
14 Corey,
15
16 If it's offensive to you, then talk to the other trustees about it. Probably
17 best to use the secret, private trustees alias where most of the trustee
18 communication goes on these days. Sheesh. Open communication? Are you sure
19 about that? I have not seen any. I am not Dr. Phil so I'll avoid jumping
20 into the middle of this communication issue. It's not my responsibility or
21 place to fix it. Now that you know that the problem exists, you can try to
22 fix it if you want.
23
24 I am also not going to rehash the various issues between me and Kurt here as
25 it would not help move anything forward. If you are not aware of them then
26 you have not been paying attention. I'd like to put them behind me but they
27 continue to reappear as part of a pattern that resurfaces again and again
28 and again. I do not want to debate whether this is "reality" or just "my
29 impression" as it would lead to another fruitless debate with Kurt. So I
30 will settle for saying that it's my clear impression that there is a pattern
31 here that continues surfacing even when I try to put past issues behind us.
32
33 I was working with Kurt because he controls infrastructure, he controls
34 adverstising, and from personal experience I know that nothing happens in
35 these areas at all unless Kurt is OK with it. That is just standard
36 operating procedure on this project. Things that get his approval happen
37 very quickly, and things that don't get held up in discussion for months of
38 consensus-building, group-thought and over-analysis. Things happen easily
39 for friends of his, but do not happen easily for others. Whether or not that
40 is reality (I do not want to start another debate about that,) this is the
41 very real impression I have of how this project operates, both when I was on
42 this project and after I resigned. For what it's worth, I am also *not the
43 only person* with this impression. There are other Gentoo developers who
44 have reached this impression independently, though their own independent
45 personal experiences. They have posted to Gentoo-dev about it. This should
46 not be news to you.
47
48 The thing I am comfortable saying without touching on intra-trustee issues
49 -- I'm not comfortable giving Kurt information because it gives him
50 additional things to discuss for months and months to hold up important
51 decisions. If you have not experienced this, then be glad you're his friend!
52 It's not nearly as pleasant for those of us who aren't.
53
54 I hope I have been "open" enough without "opening" up additional cans of
55 worms. I'm also hoping that we're able to make the transition from worms to
56 gummi worms at some point in the future.
57
58 Sincerely,
59
60 Daniel
61
62
63 --
64 gentoo-trustees@g.o mailing list

Replies

Subject Author
Re: [gentoo-trustees] store and foundation.. Corey Shields <cshields@g.o>
Re: [gentoo-trustees] store and foundation.. Kurt Lieber <klieber@g.o>