Gentoo Archives: gentoo-trustees

From: Corey Shields <cshields@g.o>
To: gentoo-trustees@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-trustees] store and foundation..
Date: Sat, 20 Nov 2004 20:07:51
Message-Id: 419FA415.1030906@gentoo.org
In Reply to: RE: [gentoo-trustees] store and foundation.. by drobbins
1 drobbins wrote:
2
3 >Corey,
4 >
5 >If it's offensive to you, then talk to the other trustees about it. Probably
6 >best to use the secret, private trustees alias where most of the trustee
7 >communication goes on these days. Sheesh. Open communication? Are you sure
8 >about that? I have not seen any. I am not Dr. Phil so I'll avoid jumping
9 >into the middle of this communication issue. It's not my responsibility or
10 >place to fix it. Now that you know that the problem exists, you can try to
11 >fix it if you want.
12 >
13 >
14 I thought I -was- trying.. maybe it wasn't that obvious. I'll try
15 harder. As for the other trustees about it, they are not making any
16 accusations that I have seen so I haven't talked to them about it (they
17 are reading this so are free to speak up).
18
19 To me, your statement sounded like an accusation that Kurt had something
20 going on behind the scenes, like benefitting from Gentoo or something.
21 I don't believe this is the case, and why I took offense to it. Your
22 further statements clear up those accusations a bit for me.
23
24 <snip>
25
26 >I was working with Kurt because he controls infrastructure, he controls
27 >adverstising, and from personal experience I know that nothing happens in
28 >these areas at all unless Kurt is OK with it. That is just standard
29 >operating procedure on this project. Things that get his approval happen
30 >very quickly, and things that don't get held up in discussion for months of
31 >consensus-building, group-thought and over-analysis. Things happen easily
32 >for friends of his, but do not happen easily for others. Whether or not that
33 >is reality (I do not want to start another debate about that,) this is the
34 >very real impression I have of how this project operates, both when I was on
35 >this project and after I resigned. For what it's worth, I am also *not the
36 >only person* with this impression. There are other Gentoo developers who
37 >have reached this impression independently, though their own independent
38 >personal experiences. They have posted to Gentoo-dev about it. This should
39 >not be news to you.
40 >
41 >
42 Yeah, I can't argue this.. But, if you are talking about issues dealing
43 with the Store's relationship to the Foundation, then maybe that should
44 have gone to the foundation as a group instead of to Kurt.
45
46 >The thing I am comfortable saying without touching on intra-trustee issues
47 >-- I'm not comfortable giving Kurt information because it gives him
48 >additional things to discuss for months and months to hold up important
49 >decisions. If you have not experienced this, then be glad you're his friend!
50 >It's not nearly as pleasant for those of us who aren't.
51 >
52 >
53 I don't know what there is to hide here.. if you are talking about the
54 suggestions I made previously about Store reports, how much the NFP is
55 costing, etc.. I don't see how that information could be used to hold
56 stuff up. In my mind the lack of it would do just that.
57
58 >I hope I have been "open" enough without "opening" up additional cans of
59 >worms. I'm also hoping that we're able to make the transition from worms to
60 >gummi worms at some point in the future.
61 >
62 >
63 Sure, I hope so as well. Trying to be neutral here, as I still
64 consider you both friends, if you both want to transition from this,
65 then you both will have to put the past behind you and move on. This
66 hasn't -truly- happened, but rather problems build upon previous
67 problems. You mentioned trying to put the past behind you before in the
68 paragraph I snipped (for the length of this msg), but then later in the
69 e-mail you drew on past experiences. This has happened on both ends of
70 the issue this time and in times past..
71
72 Whether you both work it out or not, that's up to you.. What does
73 concern me is letting one person-person conflict disrupt the work
74 between the store and the foundation. If we all had to get along well
75 with everyone else on the development team in order to do out work,
76 Gentoo wouldn't exist. That's sad, yes, but true. I would like to see
77 the work go forward despite any disagreements, and as far as my
78 suggestions yesterday, that should be possible.
79
80 Cheers,
81
82 -Corey
83
84 --
85 gentoo-trustees@g.o mailing list