1 |
Paul Stear <gentoo@××××××××××××.com> posted |
2 |
200902131208.43536.gentoo@××××××××××××.com, excerpted below, on Fri, 13 |
3 |
Feb 2009 12:08:43 +0000: |
4 |
|
5 |
> Can somebody send me a copy of their xorg.config that is used with 1 |
6 |
> graphics card and 2 identical monitors, side by side. I have read |
7 |
> various documents and have now locked up my machine twice, it seems a |
8 |
> bit hit and miss. options and sections are different in every document I |
9 |
> have read. |
10 |
|
11 |
I'm doing that (except that I stack my monitors) with a Radeon 9200 card |
12 |
with the freedomware drivers, and have been since I switched to |
13 |
freedomware Linux as an alternative to eXPrivacy in 2001 (tho the first |
14 |
year or so was with an nVidia card and the proprietary driver). |
15 |
|
16 |
You don't mention anything about your setup except the two monitors one |
17 |
card thing. As Martin suggests, the first order of business is |
18 |
determining which card and drivers you use; in particular, whether they |
19 |
are RandR[1] compliant and at what level (RandR 1.0, 1.1, 2.0, etc). A |
20 |
LOT of the documentation out there will be for a pre-RandR setup, and |
21 |
that's not going to work well on a RandR compliant driver/card combo. |
22 |
Similarly, the RandR based documentation isn't going to work well on a |
23 |
pre-RandR setup. |
24 |
|
25 |
Then of course there's the proprietary drivers, which being proprietary |
26 |
you go to the maker for support with as the general native freedomware |
27 |
documentation may or may not apply. |
28 |
|
29 |
So... if your system is uses an older Radeon series card and you're using |
30 |
the freedomware xf86-video-ati Radeon driver, my config may well help. |
31 |
If you're using a RandR compliant card and driver, it should still be |
32 |
helpful but perhaps not as much. If you're using a pre-RandR driver, my |
33 |
current config won't be a lot of help (and would only be confusing, the |
34 |
reason I'm not posting it without knowing) but as I've some experience |
35 |
with it over the years, I (and others here) will hopefully still be able |
36 |
to help. If you're using proprietaryware drivers such as nVidia or |
37 |
atiglx or whatever they call it, I may be of some very limited help on |
38 |
specific questions provided the driver works as the freedomware |
39 |
documentation (either RandR or not) states, but others are likely to be |
40 |
far more helpful and if you're lucky, the proprietaryware documentation |
41 |
is upto date and applies as well. |
42 |
|
43 |
So first up, what brand and model card, what drivers, what version of |
44 |
xorg-server are you running, and if you know or can find out, is the |
45 |
driver RandR compliant or not? |
46 |
|
47 |
--- |
48 |
[1] RandR, Resize and Rotate, X.org's quite new "dynamic" configuration |
49 |
setup. You can still configure it in xorg.conf, but ideally (as in, if |
50 |
everything works as it's supposed to), you don't need an xorg.conf any |
51 |
more as the system detects things correctly including plugging in |
52 |
additional equipment with xorg running and Just Works (TM). RandR |
53 |
doesn't yet have the same level of static configuration flexibility in |
54 |
some instances that the older method did and can be somewhat buggy on |
55 |
certain card/drivers, but the big thing it's supposed to do along with a |
56 |
similar module for plugable input devices, provided everything works |
57 |
right, is kill the need for xorg.conf entirely. |
58 |
|
59 |
So the question there is have you tried running without an xorg.conf at |
60 |
all? If you're lucky, it Just Works (TM). |
61 |
|
62 |
-- |
63 |
Duncan - List replies preferred. No HTML msgs. |
64 |
"Every nonfree program has a lord, a master -- |
65 |
and if you use the program, he is your master." Richard Stallman |