Re: [gentoo-dev] Sunrise trusted committers with bugzilla access

[Bryan Østergaard]

On Wed, Sep 13, 2006 at 11:39:16PM +0200, Stefan Schweizer wrote:
> To my fellow Gentoo developers,
>
> in the Sunrise project we have some users who are ambitious and cotribute
> more than a few ebuilds. Those regulars have the possibility to take the
> ebuild quiz and acquire the title "Sunrise trusted committer". Those
> sunrise committers can use extended bugzilla permissions to edit keywords
> EBUILD and REQUEST for example in the maintainer-wanted@ and
> maintainer-needed@ bugzilla region where usually developers clean up litle
> or have no interest in spending time on.
>
> Now I tried to get this done with the "[GLEP] Bugzilla access for
> contributors" and I was told it is to undefined and misses out the point of
> removing access levels again. Also I was told that a GLEP for this is
> overkill.
>
> All this is addressed and working with the current arch testers procedure.
> The plan is to just treat Sunrise trusted committers the same as arch or
> herd testers. The difference is that they operate on ebuilds of all
> flavours that interest themself in the sunrise overlay and not on a certain
> herd of packages. Neither do they focus on testing for a specific
> architecture. Just coding is their work, not testing - which explains the
> difference in the name.
>
> Now how do people feel about this approach?
>
As there's been very little, if any, interest from anybody besides
Stefan and Recruiters / Developer Relations I'm going to deny the
contributor access idea. Recruiters and Developer Relations feels that
this is a bad idea, especially seeing how hard it has been to reach any
kind of resolution regarding who should get access and how we should
solve the problems that I've outlined earlier.

Regards,
Bryan Østergaard
-- 
gentoo-dev@g.o mailing list