1 |
On Sat, 20 Jul 2019 20:28:39 +0200 Michał Górny wrote: |
2 |
> On Sat, 2019-07-20 at 20:50 +0300, Andrew Savchenko wrote: |
3 |
> > On Wed, 17 Jul 2019 15:25:10 +0200 Michał Górny wrote: |
4 |
> > > Hello, |
5 |
> > > |
6 |
> > > The QA team would like to introduce the following policy: |
7 |
> > > |
8 |
> > > """ |
9 |
> > > Packages must not disable installing manpages via USE flags (e.g. |
10 |
> > > USE=man or USE=doc). If upstream does not ship prebuilt manpages |
11 |
> > > and building them requires additional dependencies, the maintainer |
12 |
> > > should build them and ship along with the package. |
13 |
> > > """ |
14 |
> > > |
15 |
> > > |
16 |
> > > Explanatory note: |
17 |
> > > |
18 |
> > > This applies to having USE flags that specifically control building |
19 |
> > > manpages. It obviously does not affect: |
20 |
> > > |
21 |
> > > a. USE flags that disable building both a program and its manpage (e.g. |
22 |
> > > if USE=gui disables building gfrobnicate, not installing gfrobnicate(1) |
23 |
> > > is correct), |
24 |
> > > |
25 |
> > > b. use of LINGUAS to control installed manpages. |
26 |
> > > |
27 |
> > > |
28 |
> > > Rationale: |
29 |
> > > |
30 |
> > > Manpages are the basic form of user documentation on Gentoo Linux. Not |
31 |
> > > installing them is harmful to our users. On the other hand, requiring |
32 |
> > > additional dependencies is inconvenient. Therefore, packaging prebuilt |
33 |
> > > manpages (whenever upstream doesn't do that already) is a good |
34 |
> > > compromise that provides user with documentation without additional |
35 |
> > > dependencies. |
36 |
> > > |
37 |
> > > |
38 |
> > > What are your comments? |
39 |
> > |
40 |
> > The basic foundation of Gentoo is freedom of choise for our users. |
41 |
> > If installing man pages means no additional dependencies, than |
42 |
> > proposed rule is ok. However if such dependencies are required it is |
43 |
> > up to users to decide if they wan them or not. |
44 |
> > |
45 |
> > Having USE=man (or USE=doc) for such purposes is fine. Having |
46 |
> > USE=man enabled by default in user profile is also fine. Forcing |
47 |
> > users to install unnecessary dependencies on minimal systems in a |
48 |
> > no go and turns Gentoo into something else. |
49 |
> > |
50 |
> |
51 |
> Could you please read the proposed policy? It explicitly says you are |
52 |
> *not* supposed to force extra deps on users but build manpages for them. |
53 |
|
54 |
Could you please what the other developers have already replied to |
55 |
you on this matter? This will be a significant increase in |
56 |
maintenance burden for both developers and advanced users without |
57 |
much to gain. |
58 |
|
59 |
Best regards, |
60 |
Andrew Savchenko |