Gentoo Archives: gentoo-dev

From: Daniel Goller <morfic@g.o>
To: gentoo-dev@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-dev] Re: Last rites for media-video/dvdrip
Date: Wed, 14 Dec 2005 05:00:56
Message-Id: 200512132258.13145.morfic@gentoo.org
In Reply to: [gentoo-dev] Re: Last rites for media-video/dvdrip by R Hill
1 On Sunday 11 December 2005 09:32 pm, R Hill wrote:
2 > Diego 'Flameeyes' Petten wrote:
3 > > Oh well, media-video/dvdrip has many issues reported in bugzilla (some
4 > > have patches, most haven't), and depends on a version of transcode with
5 > > many issues, too (and force us to leave transcode 1 masked).
6 > > Nobody in video herd is looking at it right now, last bump was done by
7 > > morfic, and more would be needed.
8 >
9 > working on dvdrip is one of the things on my todo list, as soon as i finish
10 > rebuilding my system.
11 >
12 > please reconsider dropping packages just because they don't currently have
13 > a dedicated maintainer. if upstream is alive and people are using it,
14 > leave it alone. especially if it's a popular package with just a handful
15 > of bugs. also, it's a lot more likely you'll find a new maintainer for a
16 > package when it's already in the tree for people to discover and use.
17 >
18 > isn't this what the maintainer-needed alias is for?
19 >
20 > --de.
21
22
23 sorry there hasn't happened much yet wrt dvd::rip
24 the system i worked on with dvdrip had a disk die, art of a md0, system is
25 gone, so i too reinstall, some real life worries and usual lack of enough
26 time for everything
27
28 i started out keeping icewm maintained, and eventually took on other things
29
30 short version is better i guess: we always appreciate user contributions, if i
31 am slow, it does not represent any lack of interest
32
33 between you and chandler dvd::rip s hould stay, one concern is that transcode
34 1 i had on the laptop, on the system dvd::rip worked on has 0.6.14, when i
35 tried dvd::rip on here, it seems to have finished the plugin scan the hangs,
36 scanning plugins was what i did on the XP, then the hdd died :)
37
38 i too am frightened to see good working apps go, i still consider readding
39 kcpuload which worked then was gone, works still well from an overlay ;)
40
41 you get the idea
42
43 i will add your email to the dvd::rip filter in kmail so i hopefully do not
44 miss things
45
46 wife's surgery is friday, so i don't expect to do much before then
47
48 Thanks,
49
50 Daniel Goller