Gentoo Archives: gentoo-dev

From: Christian Parpart <trapni@g.o>
To: gentoo-dev@l.g.o
Subject: [gentoo-dev] ebuild design issue regarding some {I need the lib and api only}-DEPENDs
Date: Thu, 18 Aug 2005 14:10:14
Message-Id: 200508181628.44059.trapni@gentoo.org
1 Hi all,
2
3 well, regarding the request on bug 88490 [1] (and my own needs) I'm in a deep
4 problem ;)
5
6 There *are* packages out there, that depend on (networking) client libraries
7 (and their headers of course);
8
9 for the general mysql ebuild, I'd propose the following splitup:
10 * dev-db/mysql-server (or myssqld)
11 * net-libs/libmysqlclient
12 * dev-db/mysql (a meta package that simply depends on both, for backward
13 compat)
14
15 The reason is, that some packages need to talk to (SQL )servers, but some host
16 installation do not need - or even want to (think about security policies) -
17 a local (SQL) server;
18
19 Using the "minimal" useflag for this - IMHO - is a misuse of the idea of
20 "minimal" semantically - as I do understand minimal in a way like "don't
21 overbloat me with patches and other feature additions"-alike.
22
23 This idea of course is applicable for lots of more packages, but mysql is one
24 use case where I myself ran into;
25
26 Do we have a general accepted gentoo policy for this?
27
28 And... any thoughts on this subject?
29
30 Regards,
31 Christian Parpart.
32
33 [1] http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=88490
34 --
35 15:56:43 up 148 days, 5:04, 2 users, load average: 1.32, 1.21, 1.21

Replies