Gentoo Archives: gentoo-dev

From: Alexander Berntsen <bernalex@g.o>
To: gentoo-dev@l.g.o
Subject: Re: Facilitating user contributed ebuilds (Was: [gentoo-dev] The future of the Sunrise project)
Date: Wed, 15 Jun 2016 07:37:46
Message-Id: 576105BD.1000201@gentoo.org
In Reply to: Re: Facilitating user contributed ebuilds (Was: [gentoo-dev] The future of the Sunrise project) by Rich Freeman
1 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
2 Hash: SHA512
3
4 You've got most things right, Rich. But a couple of comments follow.
5
6 On 15/06/16 02:25, Rich Freeman wrote:
7 > 1. Developers wouldn't have access to all the ebuilds in the
8 > curated repositories. They would only have access to the ones they
9 > contribute to.
10 I'm not sure I completely agree with that as a hard rule. E.g. I think
11 that having an inter-repository QA team would be valuable.
12
13 > 2. Exherbo at least requires peer review for all commits I
14 > believe. So, even if you're committing to your "own" overlay you're
15 > still going to need review if your overlay is a curated one.
16 Once again you are misrepresenting Exherbo. But since this thread is
17 about Gentoo, I will limit my reply to Gentoo. We should not enforce
18 anything on a user's repository like this. Instead, I suggest we
19 maintain a fork of their repository in which we perform review.
20 - --
21 Alexander
22 bernalex@g.o
23 https://secure.plaimi.net/~alexander
24 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
25 Version: GnuPG v2
26
27 iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJXYQW7AAoJENQqWdRUGk8BGv4P/ieFcyRD1Be2Qqoj3/l90Vt0
28 3ga1EYzU1UI8nIkXXAYHChG+POMVadN73dkq/K7M/VGZbW5wAJZcCXfzC08T3rPa
29 5PROH8UmBnp5Y30tZiNrhI3cNyqUgV/V6E16WHAInPyQ1lOZp2csw9PZV7lu27PE
30 vHpjb0wmEugJNNMQrJclbMQa11PW+elI7/cgHvRCdFq3ptuaCJ6yyAkWJ+ouB4C0
31 8WpVelra2l+b0YwBYYXQ4A9qlkIFfa6Ptvkirk/J9Nrjjnj++8Exa1D9sayUmuQr
32 Iw8eTRYVUi0i1PQtTHBr6oEXMKjSdy1y1pb22O4ypflhcrj0IyhWZnIvdwDZkLzm
33 6abobiN79kzTgD8J45T2afcGKbtUIITldhgbS3GuxC6E1XjE6ByVswmh7MXT2cJa
34 l4lddH77KTdb+m0dbL6PuojTdyVKmlEyRJRr+iAEN7Fo3CSa7BE1ButdOssoNj6X
35 NIJLsHpGUVkGqSnar3f0lIe0hQqMdIEOSLqCkAkO6+OjA2nIbcgNAZXRHhJcGoB5
36 K1Nna/nCZm+GcQtlsKYvK+XyDHiLQn5QO0F6MMo5DUbxjcDR+0neKxrm12oShDFG
37 iGZDzcryAy7eZrycMR8o3RqEUf7vGk3Ve3eFgSMiGqQfaIp0Oogc4Meolk6ALKpG
38 YZ2JhKLp5efThPSaim85
39 =dWzl
40 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Replies