Re: [gentoo-dev] GLEP ??: Critical News Reporting

[Alec Warner]

Ciaran McCreesh wrote:

>On Tue, 1 Nov 2005 13:39:24 +0100 Jakub Moc <jakub@g.o> wrote:
>| Uhm... emerge sync is a *bad* time to display upgrade messages, it's
>| simply irrelevant at that time, I'm not upgrading anything at the
>| moment and might not be upgrading for next week or so.
>
>It doesn't display the messages. It displays a note saying "you have
>unread news items".
>
>| The messages should be displayed when I'm about to upgrade an ebuild
>| which has an upgrade note associated with the new version. Sending
>| mail via cron might be a nice optional feature for those who want to
>| use it.
>
>Not really a good idea, a) because news items aren't tied directly to
>ebuilds, and b) because people like advance warning of "when you
>upgrade Apache, all hell will break loose!" rather than having it
>sprung on them suddenly when they're trying to do a quick update.
>Getting the news item in advance allows for planning.
>
>
>
Personally, I'm for both.  E-mailing cron output is a relatively simple 
operation.  Adding a red flashy deal to emerge saying hey, package X has 
an unread news item, also simple as long as the read/unread format is 
non-complex.  Having emerge --news, I dislike emmensely.  We have emerge 
--changelog, and contrary to what someone posted above, it shows up 
whenever you specify -l.  However changelog does have it's fair share of 
problems, mostly people who don't use the correct changelog format and 
break the tagging, causing -l to display nothing.

If you want to make a seperate program to read the news, go for it.  I 
don't see why we have to stick silly things in a core utility.  emerge 
is a package manager, it does not do your laundry too.

-Alec Warner (Antarus)
-- 
gentoo-dev@g.o mailing list