1 |
Hanno's previous message about the LXDE project made me think other |
2 |
desktop projects that are facing a bad state in Gentoo: Cinnamon and |
3 |
Mate. They are both outdated and last I tried, Cinnamon didn't even |
4 |
build for me (bug open for a ~year now). |
5 |
|
6 |
https://repology.org/maintainer/cinnamon%40gentoo.org |
7 |
outdated: 86.7 % |
8 |
|
9 |
https://repology.org/maintainer/mate%40gentoo.org |
10 |
outdated: 97.4 % |
11 |
|
12 |
Mate doesn't seem to be that much behind. Gentoo has 1.22 and latest |
13 |
release is 1.24. 1.22 was released 2019-03-18, and 1.24 last month. Many |
14 |
of the packages are outdated in a sense that these packages have minor |
15 |
releases, which haven't been packaged in Gentoo. Ie 1.22.3. |
16 |
There was a 1.23 release in-between, but looks like not many distros |
17 |
packaged that either. (Might be some full-development version?) |
18 |
|
19 |
Cinnamon on the other hand is _horribly_ outdated. Gentoo has 4.0 while |
20 |
latest release is 4.4. And as noted, I couldn't even build it while |
21 |
trying. 4.0.3 was released in Nov 2018, while the latest 4.4.8 Jan 2020. |
22 |
The have been _numerous_ releases in between. |
23 |
|
24 |
Should some general consensus be agreed on whether to keep them or |
25 |
remove them? I feel like we are lying to any new users installing |
26 |
Gentoo; When they setup their system and boot into installed DE, they |
27 |
immediately have to resort to some overlay to update it. While they |
28 |
should get it from the overlay in the first place. Saying, IF they even |
29 |
manage to build it (Cinnamon). This came up and was discussed in the |
30 |
Gentoo forums. |
31 |
|
32 |
There could be more issues these non-maintained big projects cause, like |
33 |
enabling elogind distrowide. |
34 |
|
35 |
cinnamon@g.o has been assigned to 27 open bugs, mate@g.o |
36 |
to 33. |
37 |
|
38 |
This message also works as a call-to-arms with these projects. Even if |
39 |
people decide to rather keep them in ::gentoo, help and some action is |
40 |
needed. |