1 |
Hi, |
2 |
|
3 |
I think the time has come for me to retire as a gentoo dev. There are |
4 |
multiple reasons to that, but mainly, it has stopped being fun a good |
5 |
while ago, and I don't like where I see the project heading. |
6 |
|
7 |
One of the main reasons that I am involved in free software in the first |
8 |
place is because of I value things like freedom or openness, and not |
9 |
only for code. I don't see gentoo caring very much for those today, and |
10 |
worst, I can only see the situation getting worse on those matters. I am |
11 |
also worried about power in gentoo, since it seems there are no |
12 |
boundaries to the council, which doesn't even feel like it needs to |
13 |
listen to what the community thinks, as was illustrated by the stupidly |
14 |
fast adoption of the Code of Conduct. And the endless fights about who |
15 |
gets a tiny bit more of power over ${media} are also starting to really |
16 |
tire me. |
17 |
|
18 |
I'm also worried of how more and more things get done secretly, be it |
19 |
because "we don't want bad PR" or because "feedback at this stage would |
20 |
only slow things down". We shouldn't consider users as idiots or people |
21 |
from whom we need to hide. This is free software, remember? |
22 |
|
23 |
Another thing that I dislike are the rules that get added everywhere. |
24 |
There is a growing layer of bureaucracy, and I really don't think we |
25 |
want to go in this direction. It restricts freedom, it takes time and |
26 |
energy and it encourages playing "by the rule book" which I thought was |
27 |
opposed to the very spirit of free software. More rules won't help us |
28 |
solving whatever problems we may have, but it will certainly make the |
29 |
project less fun to work on. |
30 |
|
31 |
I see a general trend, sometimes wished for, of becoming a business-like |
32 |
environment. Including a proper hierarchy and a "rule enforcement" |
33 |
department. Well, I'll tell you what: I don't want a boss, especially on |
34 |
a voluntary project. And, though I perfectly understand that this is not |
35 |
shared by everyone else, I couldn't care less about being a business or |
36 |
not. |
37 |
|
38 |
To end my list of griefs, I really dislike the fact that people with a |
39 |
gentoo.org address think of themselves as somehow better than users (I |
40 |
don't throw the stone to anyone, I certainly did indulge in this as |
41 |
well). I feel that gentoo is not enough about users, and that they don't |
42 |
get even the respect everyone deserves. Unfortunately, projects like |
43 |
userrel can only do so much when the real problem is in everyone's |
44 |
mindset. And I don't really see a solution to this problem being found |
45 |
anytime soon, since the said problem isn't even acknowledged. |
46 |
|
47 |
|
48 |
I'm aware that in a perfect world, I would stay on board and try to |
49 |
steer the project in a direction that I would like. I tried that for a |
50 |
bit and it was quite obvious that I wouldn't be supported by a |
51 |
significant part of the community. And I don't have the time nor energy |
52 |
to lobby this properly. I had some ideas for a metastructure proposal |
53 |
that would perhaps have helped some of the issues I talked about, but I |
54 |
honestly don't think it would have stood any chance of being accepted, |
55 |
especially since it would have meant suppressing the council power *and* |
56 |
would have needed to be voted by the same council. |
57 |
So I can only hope that things will change for the better in the future, |
58 |
perhaps with a fork, which, if done properly, would imho help a lot with |
59 |
the currently perceived issues. |
60 |
|
61 |
|
62 |
|
63 |
Now, for some technical points about packages I used to maintain: |
64 |
- ml is left in good hands since aballier actively takes care of it |
65 |
- tex is basically unmaintained. Perhaps ehmsen can be talked out of |
66 |
MIA, though I guess he's pretty busy at the moment, and Opfer also |
67 |
seemed quite interested. I've received a couple offers from users who |
68 |
would like to get more involved but so far no one really helped much |
69 |
with bugs. The new tex guy will also have the big task of preparing |
70 |
the switch from tetex to texlive. |
71 |
- math-proof didn't work as well as expected, mainly because I didn't |
72 |
have enough time to populate it properly. coq can probably go back to |
73 |
ml but agda is maintainer-needed. If someone is willing to proxy me, I |
74 |
can continue doing it (should be very low volume). |
75 |
- misc packages, can probably go back into respective herds: |
76 |
- media-gfx/llgal |
77 |
- media-gfx/ufraw |
78 |
- media-sound/lltag |
79 |
- media-libs/exiftool |
80 |
|
81 |
There are drafts for a LaTeX documentation, untouched in a year or so on |
82 |
my devspace, I saved a copy if needed. The current stable tetex release |
83 |
has in SRC_URI a tarball located in my home, I didn't know how to handle |
84 |
this properly so please poke me before erasing the whole thing (I have a |
85 |
local copy as well). Everything else is unimportant. I trust devrel to |
86 |
wipe me out on every other medium :) |
87 |
|
88 |
I can still be reached at the email address |
89 |
|
90 |
alexandre DOT buisse AT ens-lyon DOT org |
91 |
|
92 |
and chances are I'll still hang around irc. |
93 |
|
94 |
|
95 |
As a final word (sorry, this got a bit longer than planned), let me say |
96 |
that if I sounded bitter in the beginning of this email, it's only |
97 |
because I care a lot about gentoo, and I hope that this email, in its |
98 |
modest way, will help making it a little bit better. And I would like to |
99 |
thank everyone involved for the great time I had during this year and a |
100 |
half of devship! |
101 |
|
102 |
See you on the other side, |
103 |
/Alexandre |
104 |
-- |
105 |
Hi, I'm a .signature virus! Please copy me in your ~/.signature. |