1 |
On Thu, Aug 29, 2013 at 1:49 PM, Rich Freeman <rich0@g.o> wrote: |
2 |
> |
3 |
> Please don't interpret anything I'm saying as a lack of care for small |
4 |
> archs. I'd just rather see them define their goals in terms of things |
5 |
> they can actually accomplish and then accomplish those. Having a |
6 |
> bunch of ancient stable versions that are just weighing down the rest |
7 |
> of the distro isn't really a good measure of success. That was why I |
8 |
> suggested the possible @system-only compromise - it might be a way to |
9 |
> capture some of the value of having stable keywords while greatly |
10 |
> reducing the amount of work involved. Better to do less but do it |
11 |
> properly. |
12 |
> |
13 |
|
14 |
I didn't really get any response to this one way or another. At the |
15 |
last council meeting a majority of the votes were in favor of delaying |
16 |
taking action, so this is back on the agenda. |
17 |
I have yet to see either of the following on this list: |
18 |
1. Specific examples of bugs where a minor arch is making a |
19 |
maintainer's life difficult. Please post if you have them. |
20 |
2. Members of these arch teams posting here committing to either |
21 |
stabilize new versions or unkeyword old versions in a timely manner. |
22 |
|
23 |
The responses to either of these (or lack thereof) are likely to |
24 |
influence my vote at the meeting. Note, I'm not interested in mere |
25 |
comments that people want an arch to stay stable supported (which I've |
26 |
seen plenty of). I'm interested in COMMITMENT to be |
27 |
stable-supportable (which I've seen none of). The lack of the latter |
28 |
is what is going to cause a package to be dropped - I'd love to see |
29 |
every arch that exists stable-supported on Gentoo, along with world |
30 |
peace. This is a volunteer distro - in general you get the features |
31 |
you pitch in to help deliver, and if you're depending on a minor arch |
32 |
you REALLY need to step up as there aren't many of you out there. |
33 |
That said, I would like specific examples of cases where dropping a |
34 |
minor arch would have helped - the onus is on those wanting the status |
35 |
quo changed to present a case. |
36 |
|
37 |
Rich |