1 |
Maybe I should have reflected more on the original post before replying |
2 |
too. When I read the original post, it seemed to be a sincere resignation |
3 |
email. Upon further reflection, I do feel that it was unprofessional to |
4 |
call individuals out -- *even if* the account was 100% accurate (which it |
5 |
appears there is some doubt about.) |
6 |
|
7 |
If someone had a bad experience as a dev for Gentoo, then fine -- share |
8 |
your experience in the hopes that things will improve. But don't name |
9 |
names. That isn't professional. If you didn't have a good experience, yes, |
10 |
that's legitimate feedback.It provides an opportunity to look at the |
11 |
*project as a whole* and say 'how can we do things better' by improving |
12 |
processes, etc. so that new devs have a better experience. That can be |
13 |
shared without calling individuals out. It is not necessary or helpful to |
14 |
defame people. |
15 |
|
16 |
Mgorny was maligned in the post. That wasn't right, and for my part I |
17 |
apologize for 'grabbing the bait' and accepting the original poster's |
18 |
account at face value. |
19 |
|
20 |
So, my new, amended response to the original poster: Ugh. I am sincerely |
21 |
sorry you had a bad experience. Critical feedback is welcome. But let's not |
22 |
defame people. Perpetuating hostility towards individuals, even if |
23 |
perceived as being deserved, if anything just makes things worse and |
24 |
undermines your points. And to solve any problems, the solution needs to be |
25 |
geared towards finding ways to improve the project as a whole rather than |
26 |
'punishing' individuals. So we need to get out of that mindset to move |
27 |
forward. An eye for an eye leaves the world blind. |
28 |
|
29 |
Sincerely, |
30 |
|
31 |
-Daniel |
32 |
|
33 |
On Sat, Jan 13, 2018 at 8:00 PM, Matthew Thode <prometheanfire@g.o> |
34 |
wrote: |
35 |
|
36 |
> On 17-12-16 00:34:03, Daniel Campbell wrote: |
37 |
> > |
38 |
> > mgorny again showed up; this time accusing me of being a "do-nothing |
39 |
> > politician". Thankfully, I kept an activity log of everything I did for |
40 |
> > the Foundation, and `git log --committer=zlg@g.o` will show you |
41 |
> > everything I did in the tree. Yes, I made mistakes. Some of them rookie |
42 |
> > ones. But given that I wasn't being paid for my work, and time spent |
43 |
> > on Gentoo meant time I couldn't spend on other things (like personal |
44 |
> > projects), I needed to make a value decision: was I willing to continue |
45 |
> > donating labor to an organization that didn't notice my work unless |
46 |
> > I screwed up? If I was truly as ineffectual as those who claimed it |
47 |
> > (rich0), what was the point of continuing? The cricitism I received |
48 |
> > during my time as a developer was demotivating and didn't acknowledge |
49 |
> > any of the *correct* things I did; how exactly was I going to improve? |
50 |
> > |
51 |
> |
52 |
> zlg has made comments about rich0 that he as been asked to verify. As |
53 |
> there has been no response to the request for more information, the |
54 |
> Trustees are retracting the comment and wish to apologize to rich0 for |
55 |
> the inconvenience. |
56 |
> |
57 |
> -- |
58 |
> Matthew Thode (prometheanfire) |
59 |
> President, Gentoo Foundation |
60 |
> |