Gentoo Archives: gentoo-user

From: William Kenworthy <billk@×××××××××.au>
To: gentoo-user@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-user] Encrypted hard drives on LVM and urgent power shutdowns.
Date: Mon, 12 Sep 2022 05:08:31
Message-Id: 550b03e7-d11e-2d01-f058-86069a45555b@iinet.net.au
In Reply to: [gentoo-user] Encrypted hard drives on LVM and urgent power shutdowns. by Dale
1 If your using nut, it has to be setup - and should be regularly tested
2 to make sure it works.
3
4 BillK
5
6 '
7
8 On 12/9/22 09:56, Dale wrote:
9 > Howdy,
10 >
11 > Last night we had some bad weather where I live and we ended up with
12 > some power problems.  Ironically they went out a few hours after the
13 > storm was gone.  Anyway.  I had all sorts of encrypted drives open.  My
14 > usual drives inside my puter plus the large 14TB external backup drive
15 > that is still copying files over.  Glad my UPS held up while I closed
16 > all those drives and did a proper shutdown.  Doing all that tho, it made
17 > me think about if I wasn't here to do all that.  Being Linux, I'd
18 > suspect that upsmon would tell the puter to do a proper shutdown which
19 > includes unmounting the file system, closing the encrypted drives, like
20 > I do with cryptsetup close <name> etc and then shutting down.  However,
21 > one has to ask, is it set up to do so by default?  I manage the
22 > encrypted drives manually.  I don't use the crypt services for that like
23 > people do when all of the system drive(s) is encrypted or when just
24 > /home is encrypted.  My encrypted stuff is mounted within /home or for
25 > the external backups, in /mnt.  Thing is, some aren't open unless I'm
26 > using them or are external.  Since I do it manually, is there a tool
27 > that sees they need unmounting and closing and does it or do I need to
28 > do something to make sure it is done before a shutdown?
29 >
30 > I suspect this would happen on its own but I'd like to make sure.  I'd
31 > hate to mess up the file system badly on any of my drives or in a worst
32 > case scenario, brick a hard drive with some 1 in a million chance problem.
33 >
34 > I thought about having a drive connected, open and mounted that I don't
35 > really need and just do a shutdown, see what happens.  Then again, why
36 > not ask and see if anyone else has had this happen and if things turned
37 > out OK or if there was problems.  I'm lucky, most of the time I'm either
38 > home or very close by.  Still, it can happen when I'm not here.  I
39 > already wonder if upsmon will kick in correctly and do a proper
40 > shutdown.  After all, it has never had to before.  I'm running on faith
41 > that it will.  I hope I'm right.
42 >
43 > Thoughts?  Default will take care of things?  I need to take steps to be
44 > sure in case I'm not here?  Personal experience?  A good theory?  ;-)
45 >
46 > Thanks.
47 >
48 > Dale
49 >
50 > :-)  :-)
51 >

Replies

Subject Author
Re: [gentoo-user] Encrypted hard drives on LVM and urgent power shutdowns. Dale <rdalek1967@×××××.com>