1 |
Frank Steinmetzger wrote: |
2 |
> Am Sun, Jul 25, 2021 at 06:10:19PM -0500 schrieb Dale: |
3 |
> |
4 |
>> I've tried external drives connected by USB before and hated them. Slow |
5 |
>> when they do work and buggy at that. |
6 |
> Theoretically, HDDs are not able to saturate USB 3. And from my observation, |
7 |
> I do get their maximum performance – my 2.5″ 1 TB WD delivers about 80-90 MB/s |
8 |
> read speed and said Intenso/Seagate 3.5″ gives me up to around 140 MB/s tops. |
9 |
> I used dstat to gather those numbers. |
10 |
|
11 |
I think all my USB ports are USB2. It's slower. What you post above is |
12 |
about what I get on my external eSATA. If I were using USB3, things may |
13 |
be different. Maybe. ;-) |
14 |
|
15 |
|
16 |
>> I've had more drives go bad when using USB enclosures than I've ever had |
17 |
>> on IDE or (e)SATA. |
18 |
> Interesting, I can’t really confirm such a correlation from the drives I |
19 |
> have lying around. And I don’t see how USB can cause damage to a drive. |
20 |
> Except for physical impacts owing to the fact that USB drives are easily |
21 |
> moved around. |
22 |
> |
23 |
|
24 |
Those particular drives sat on the desk next to my computer. They |
25 |
rarely moved. Heck, I rarely unplugged them. Just turn them off when |
26 |
done. |
27 |
|
28 |
|
29 |
>> I've had two drives fail after years of service that were IDE or SATA. I |
30 |
>> have three drives that are bricks and all of them were in USB enclosures |
31 |
>> and far young to die. |
32 |
> Perhaps they became too hot during operation. Enclosures don’t usually |
33 |
> account for thermals. Didn’t you mention you lived in a hot area? |
34 |
> |
35 |
|
36 |
Every enclosure I buy has a fan. The enclosures were pretty well built |
37 |
as far as the case goes. |
38 |
|
39 |
|
40 |
>> I paid more for eSATA external enclosures and have had no |
41 |
>> problems with drives going dead yet. All of them have far surpassed the |
42 |
>> drives in the USB enclosures. |
43 |
> Hm... bad (in the sense of cheap) USB controllers on the mobo or the |
44 |
> enclosures? Or bad USB cables? What kind of HDD death are we talking about? |
45 |
> Certainly not bad sectors, right? |
46 |
> |
47 |
|
48 |
After a while I'd start getting errors and it would either remount ro or |
49 |
just unmount completely. After a while, the drives wouldn't respond at |
50 |
all. They spin up but it's as if they are not connected with the data |
51 |
cable. Eventually, I plugged them into my computer as SATA drives. |
52 |
They still wouldn't show up. It was as if they were not there. They |
53 |
did spin up tho. |
54 |
|
55 |
>> I think my drives are either Seagate or WD. I tend to stick with those |
56 |
>> two, unless it is a really awesome deal. |
57 |
> Yea. First the SMR fiasco became public and then there was some other PR |
58 |
> stunt they did that I can’t remember right now, and I said “I can’t buy WD |
59 |
> anymore”. But there is no real alternative these days. And CMR drives are |
60 |
> becoming ever rarer, especially in the 2.5″ realm. Except for one single |
61 |
> seagate model, there isn’t even a bare SATA drive above 2 TB available on |
62 |
> the market! Everything above that size is external USB stuff. And those |
63 |
> disks don’t come with standard SATA connectors anymore, but have the USB |
64 |
> socket soldered onto their PCB. |
65 |
> |
66 |
|
67 |
I bought a SMR before I was aware of the problems with them. It's just |
68 |
a backup drive but I still have to wait for it to stop bumping before I |
69 |
power it off. Sometimes it only takes a few minutes, sometimes it bumps |
70 |
for a while. The CMR I use as a backup drive, different data, is |
71 |
smaller. It doesn't do that so I can unhook it right after it finishes. |
72 |
>> I've never updated the firmware on a drive before. |
73 |
> Me neither. I think I updated an SSD once. |
74 |
> |
75 |
|
76 |
I've never had a SSD. Thinking about it tho. |
77 |
|
78 |
Hmmm, just realized I didn't do my usual Sunday updates and backups. |
79 |
Ooooops. :/ |
80 |
|
81 |
Dale |
82 |
|
83 |
:-) :-) |