1 |
Hello, |
2 |
|
3 |
On Fri, 16 Dec 2011, Joerg Schilling wrote: |
4 |
>This is interestingas some mkisofs users report that there are DVDs that look |
5 |
>as if there is a need to introduce negative padding between some files. |
6 |
|
7 |
There's DVDs that look (to e.g. lsdvd) as if there were ~60 Tracks of |
8 |
various sizes used, with a playing time of, say, 40 hours overall, |
9 |
breaking the Specs willfully. Of course, only e.g. 4 Tracks are the |
10 |
"real" tracks. Figuring out which tracks those are (e.g. playing the |
11 |
disc with xine, mplayer or vlc) and then extracting only those tracks |
12 |
with e.g. dvdbackup is the only possibility. Images etc. will be |
13 |
defective. Don't ask me how you create such interleaved tracks |
14 |
(e.g. tracks 20-35 would be various parts of a series episode but only |
15 |
one, say 27, would be the full track). I'd guess "negative padding" (at |
16 |
least in the nav-structures) might play a role there. |
17 |
|
18 |
Just this week I've had a DVD, where lsdvd just barfed. The image with |
19 |
k3b was broken. dvdbackup for single tracks worked. |
20 |
|
21 |
That's one reason I like to rent a disc before I buy a whole series. |
22 |
Actually, there's only one Movie-set that has broken (one or two out |
23 |
of 5) discs, most I own are standard conforming and some seem to not |
24 |
even bother with css. |
25 |
|
26 |
"Digital files cannot be made uncopyable, any more than water can be made |
27 |
not wet." --Bruce Schneier on `copy protection' schemes |
28 |
|
29 |
And I want to make backups of the discs I own. The less hoops I'm |
30 |
forced to jump through (with a rented disc), the more likely I am to |
31 |
buy something. There's a certain series (c.f. above) I quite like, but |
32 |
the DVDs are just plain broken. Won't buy. Period. |
33 |
|
34 |
-dnh, got to look up the publisher on above mentioned disc where lsdvd |
35 |
barfed ... ah: Cnenzbhag. I hadn't have them on my "publishes |
36 |
un-DVDs" list yet. Well, anyway, some publishers seem to start not |
37 |
to produce un-DVDs lately. Just keep sending rented disc after |
38 |
disc back as "broken" and asking for replacement ... |
39 |
|
40 |
-- |
41 |
>> Take two Gods. |
42 |
>Diagnostic. n. Someone who doubts the existence of two Gods. |
43 |
Makes sense. Every regular user of diagnostics that I know of only |
44 |
believes in Murphy. -- >>D. Holdsworth, >C. Suslowicz and Lionel |