1 |
Am 06.08.2015 um 22:01 schrieb Rich Freeman: |
2 |
> You're defining "really systemd-free" in the same sense that the FSF |
3 |
> defines a "really free" distro (they think Debian FOSS-only isn't good |
4 |
> enough). Sticking with the base profile should get you an experience |
5 |
> about the same as what you'd have gotten 4 years ago before anybody |
6 |
> heard of systemd, and going as far as you suggestion may cause |
7 |
> problems if you use software that has been subsequently merged into |
8 |
> systemd, but which is still available standalone (think udev/etc). |
9 |
> |
10 |
> But, to each their own, that is the Gentoo way. Just don't file any |
11 |
> bugs if something breaks purely as a result of doing the steps above. |
12 |
|
13 |
You're totally wrong. |
14 |
|
15 |
USE="-systemd" tells portage not to build and install optional systemd |
16 |
features, dependencies etc. Ebuilds that need systemd as a hard |
17 |
dependency like GNOME are not affected by this. |
18 |
|
19 |
The INSTALL_MASK just tells portage to not install systemd related files |
20 |
which are not necessary and not used on none-systemd systems like those |
21 |
unit files or whatever they are called which are unfortunately installed |
22 |
by several ebuilds along with the OpenRC init scripts. |
23 |
|
24 |
So, yes, I will file any bugs if something breaks, because systemd is |
25 |
supposed to be optional on Gentoo. |
26 |
|
27 |
And, no, I won't install any package which is merged into systemd. As |
28 |
you mentioned udev, what do you need udev for if you don't use systemd? |
29 |
Just install eudev. Works perfectly without any systemd dependency. |
30 |
|
31 |
And, yes, I don't like systemd - in fact I hate it - because it's just |
32 |
broken by design. But discussing with Poettering and his fanboys is |
33 |
pointless since they aren't able to take criticism. There are a lot of |
34 |
other reasons, too. |
35 |
|
36 |
And I really don't want to have any part of this Poetterix crap like |
37 |
systemd, pulseaudio etc. on my system. So I take it as a compliment when |
38 |
you compare my definition of "really systemd-free" with the FSF's |
39 |
definition of a "really free" distro. |