1 |
On Monday 14 January 2008, James wrote: |
2 |
|
3 |
> I just do not see the harm in letting a small (sub 1 million dollar |
4 |
> company) build a product and not provide any details or what they did |
5 |
> or how they did it. In the end, their success is more likely related |
6 |
> to how slick their marketing campaign is or how well conceived the |
7 |
> product/service is or how good their support is or some other twist. |
8 |
|
9 |
Well, there is nothing wrong and no harm at all. They can surely write |
10 |
their product from scratch and choose to not release any detail about |
11 |
it. In fact, many companies do this all the time. |
12 |
What is wrong is when a company or individual, to save time and money, |
13 |
decides to pick (or usurp, depending on one's point of view) an already |
14 |
existing piece of code and adapt it to their needs, without respecting |
15 |
the rules set by the author of such code (remember that the original |
16 |
author(s) of a GPLed code still retains their copyrights on the code). |
17 |
|
18 |
> The GPL goes a long way to discouraging/preventing many of the serfs |
19 |
> from ever trying.... IMHO. I believe that the GPL is the spawn of |
20 |
> satan. I think the 'serfs' (the greater gentoo community) would be |
21 |
> better off with a BSD style license related to Gentoo technologies and |
22 |
> still use GPL software, as the individual chooses. After all, most of |
23 |
> the BSD variants and derivatives (except those RTOS that large |
24 |
> corporations use in some of their products) Still manage to use GPL |
25 |
> software. |
26 |
> |
27 |
> Obviously, you think that GPL is a panacea. OK we agree to disagree. |
28 |
|
29 |
Not exactly a panacea. But I do think that the ideas in the GPL are not |
30 |
in contrast with the possibility of making money, both for small |
31 |
companies and big ones alike (and there are real-world examples to |
32 |
confirm this). Of course, all of this IMHO. Your views do have their |
33 |
good points, and I respect them. |
34 |
-- |
35 |
gentoo-user@l.g.o mailing list |