Gentoo Archives: gentoo-user

From: Dake Wang <dkwangpool@×××××.com>
To: gentoo-user@l.g.o, gentoo-user@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-user] Awesome vs Xmonad
Date: Wed, 17 Dec 2008 22:04:57
Message-Id: alpine.LNX.2.00.0812171355310.2263@localhost
In Reply to: Re: [gentoo-user] Awesome vs Xmonad by Man Shankar
1 I am an xmonad user now. I installed awesome once, but didn't try to
2 understand much details of it, so no comment on awesome.
3
4 On Wed, 17 Dec 2008, Man Shankar wrote:
5
6 > On 09:39 Wed 17 Dec , Gregory SACRE wrote:
7 >> Hi Man,
8 >>
9 >>
10 >> I was a huge fan of FVWM (loved the flexibility of it) and I tried to
11 >> switch to awesome.
12 >> After trying a bit to understand how the configuration script work
13 >> (about three days in my spare time), I understood how awesome (this
14 >> one was easy :-p) this wm is.
15 >> You can do pretty much what you want as the configuration script,
16 >> which is using the Lua script language, can load system commands (such
17 >> as conky, even thought I couldn't get it to work, but used native lua
18 >> scripts with the wicked.lua library) or run native code (I use this to
19 >> see the disk space, mpd songs, battery life, cpu usage with a graph,
20 >> ...).
21 > Sounds great but when i customize the file and save it in
22 > "~/.config/awesome/rc.lua" and reload, nothing seems to happen. I am
23 > trying to get working with awesome-3.1. Am i missing anything.
24 >>
25 >> One of the other things I really like in awesome, it's the fact that
26 >> you can mix up tiling windows and floating ones. You can define, for
27 >> certain window titles in the configuration file, the fact that they
28 >> are floating. Then, when you start them, they appear as floating
29 >> windows and not tiled as the rest of them. This is pretty much
30 >> interesting for applications such as Skype, gitk, mplayer, ...
31 >> As for other tiling wm, you can also assign tags (sort of virtual
32 >> desktops) to window titles so when you start it, it goes directly
33 >> there, leaving your actual tag clean with what you were doing.
34 >
35 > That is a required feature because some stupid programs dont go well
36 > with the tiling concept. Another neat feature i found in default xmonad
37 > was the fact that there was no gap between adjacent windows. I am sure
38 > awesome should be able to do that as well, just that the default conf
39 > doesnt. But, then again i really haven't dug in.
40 In xmonad default, the size hint of some programs are ignored. Like
41 terminal staffs, urxvt, xterm, gvim. So sometimes they will leave
42 a half line on the bottom after certain resize action, as of new
43 windows opened.
44 Solved with an HintedTile tiling mod in xmonad-contrib.
45 >
46 > --
47 >
48 > Regards,
49 > Man Shankar <man.ee.gen(at)gmail.com>
50 >
51 >