Gentoo Archives: gentoo-user

From: Dale <dalek1967@×××××××××.net>
To: gentoo-user@l.g.o
Cc: markknecht@×××××.com
Subject: Re: [gentoo-user] What's with this hald thing and why can't I rip CDs any more?
Date: Thu, 10 Jan 2008 04:48:42
Message-Id: 478597BD.5030605@bellsouth.net
In Reply to: Re: [gentoo-user] What's with this hald thing and why can't I rip CDs any more? by Mark Knecht
1 Mark Knecht wrote:
2 >
3 > Hi Dale,
4 > I disabled hald in rc-update and rebooted. Now Totem and Gnome are
5 > not auto-mounting anything. K3b can see the CD. cddb and ripping seem
6 > to work fine with hald disabled.
7 >
8 > I think the overall set of problems were:
9 >
10 > 1) sound-juicer has developed some sort of regression
11 >
12 > 2) hald & Gnome were conspiring to make my system too automatic for my tastes
13 >
14 > At this point I'm in good shape and wondering what the future is
15 > going to bring me. Am I putting off the inevitable by not letting hald
16 > have it's evil ways with my computer? Will it be required in the
17 > future? I thought a lot of that sort of automatic device stuff was
18 > supposed to be done by udev so why I need more is beyond me.
19 >
20 > Anyway, the computer is functional and I can rip with at least one
21 > app so I'm back in business.
22 >
23 > Thanks,
24 > Mark
25 >
26 LOL You must be new to Linux. You didn't need to reboot. If you want
27 to stop say, hald, just do a /etc/init.d/hald stop. That would stop the
28 service, 99% of the time anyway. If you don't want it to start up
29 anymore then you can remove it with rc-update to make it survive a
30 reboot in its stopped state.
31
32 This is my thoughts and if anyone has a better one please post away. I
33 think there is a disagreement between hald and the programs you are
34 trying to use. One or more may need to be recompiled to make them all
35 happy again. I ran into a problem like this recently with cups. Try
36 running the following and post what it says: "emerge -pv sound-juicer
37 hal totem k3b" Leave off the quotes there. Also note, that is not
38 going to actually do anything but list the packages it would install and
39 the USE flags they are compiled with. It's not going to reinstall them
40 or anything. Shouldn't take to long depending on your rigs speed.
41
42 Maybe with that we can see if it is doing something different or missing
43 something that is causing this.
44
45 Dale
46
47 :-) :-)
48
49 P.S. I sent this before but it came back as a boo boo message. Sorry
50 if it is a dup. May be off list too.