1 |
On 21/02/2013 20:52, James wrote: |
2 |
> Alan McKinnon <alan.mckinnon <at> gmail.com> writes: |
3 |
> |
4 |
>> Do you have a special need to use Plex over XBMC for the back-end? |
5 |
> |
6 |
> No. |
7 |
> |
8 |
>> I would say XBMC does everything you need. It supports profiles, which |
9 |
>> give you the password protection you mentioned, and there are many |
10 |
>> awesome front-end/remotes for android and i* in the markets. Just don't |
11 |
>> use the so-called "official XBMC remotes", that one uses an obsolete |
12 |
>> http API to XBMC, the current code base (Eden and Frodo) uses something |
13 |
>> much better in json. The best remote/front-end currently for android is |
14 |
>> Yatse IMNSHO |
15 |
> |
16 |
> All good to know. |
17 |
> |
18 |
>> Ditch gentoo entirely for this and use OpenElec instead (openelec.tv). |
19 |
>> It's XBMC on an appliance, and all of the maintenance issue you will |
20 |
>> experience (like broken libav or ffmpeg....) just ImmediatelyGoAway(tm) |
21 |
> |
22 |
> This looks promising. I need to drill deeper into the Arm chips (SOC) |
23 |
> that support OpenElec, Geexbox and such application. |
24 |
> |
25 |
> What about geexbox? How does it stack up in a comparision to what |
26 |
> you have tried? I just stumbled across it. In fact, is there |
27 |
> a good review somewhere that talks about many of these sort of HTPC |
28 |
> systems in a feature comparison? |
29 |
> |
30 |
> |
31 |
>> minidlna (in the tree) is a nice minimal media server, you get none of |
32 |
>> the xbmc awesomeness (like fanart and libraries and posters), but it's |
33 |
>> quick and fast and delivers content nicely. There are many front ends |
34 |
>> out there all speaking DLNA, and they support pushing and pulling |
35 |
>> content to varying degrees. |
36 |
> |
37 |
> Another interesting offering. |
38 |
> |
39 |
> Do any (all?) of these video servers mearly work over wired ethernet |
40 |
> or the HDMI output port, or do some of them broadcast locally over wifi, |
41 |
> which can be picked up by apple and android phones? |
42 |
> |
43 |
> My video camera can stream into a linux device via the the usb or the |
44 |
> mini HDMI port. I'm not sure how to set up a hdmi port on a linux host |
45 |
> to receive input from the hdmi output on the camera? What I want to do is |
46 |
> then rebroadcast over wifi so every phone in the local (wifi) area can |
47 |
> watch the video live on their phone as well as playback and other |
48 |
> intersperced content (player stats etc). |
49 |
> |
50 |
> What would you recommend ? |
51 |
> |
52 |
> Which apps would the iphone or the android phone run to receive the |
53 |
> wifi re-broadcasts? |
54 |
|
55 |
My setup: |
56 |
|
57 |
Content on an HP microserver with regular consumer SATA drives |
58 |
(5400rpm). Network is 100mb FastEthernet (it's a gig nic but the switch |
59 |
is 100m). It runs FreeNAS and serves content over NFS, SMB and DLNA. |
60 |
|
61 |
XBMC is latest OpenElec Frodo RC3 on an Xtreamer Ultra2, HDMI 1.4 |
62 |
straight into the TV. Sound is plain 2.0 into the the TV. Network is |
63 |
802.11n locked to 145mb (the AP is too unstable at 300 at my house). |
64 |
Uses NFS to get to backend storage. |
65 |
|
66 |
I went with this setup as I'd been burnt trying to go cheap. A |
67 |
RaspberryPi just barely managed to run 1080p and would stutter badly |
68 |
with any audio it couldn't just pass through direct to the TV. And |
69 |
there's the MPEG-2 license thingy as well.My research showed that even |
70 |
the latest ARM chips from 6 months ago were still not quite there yet |
71 |
(hopefully that will change real soon now), and the XBMC gui was |
72 |
annoyingly sluggish. Chaps at work had Popcorn hour boxes and other |
73 |
similar ARM based devices, with without the rich XBMC experience - the |
74 |
gui on all of them sucked. Probably because the device didn't have spare |
75 |
resources for a GUI. |
76 |
|
77 |
So I went for Intel based with a good nVidia card, and the XBox is the |
78 |
backup (also wireless at 145) if the Xtreamer goes south - that's what |
79 |
the DLNA is for :-) |
80 |
|
81 |
Network performance is great, even when playing full 1080p Bluray rips |
82 |
or .vob rips off dvd. I can get the network to max out, but have to do |
83 |
much crazy stuff at the same time as watch a movie to pull it off :-) |
84 |
|
85 |
I haven't looked into Geekbox at all, I understand it's a nicely |
86 |
packaged XBMC so all the same performance comparisons should hold. |
87 |
|
88 |
The way I use it on the tablets and phones is to use the functionality |
89 |
of the remote. AFAIK it asks xbmc for stuff and it comes over the |
90 |
network as uPNP, but I'm a little fuzzy on the details. It works for me, |
91 |
that's what I care about :-) I have a Samsung10" first gen tablet and an |
92 |
S2 phone, both cope well. XBMC doesn't transcode, so the device has to |
93 |
be able to deal with the content as delivered. Or, just download the |
94 |
file and watch later (that's why the content server supports smb) |
95 |
|
96 |
As for your camera, maybe OpenElec isn't the solution for that - it's a |
97 |
barebones appliance and might not support everything you need. Check out |
98 |
XBMC Live (it's also an installer) which is Ubuntu based, and you could |
99 |
use v4l to deal with the camera's video stream and broadcast that way. |
100 |
You would have to give up emerge in favour of apt-get thoguh.... |
101 |
|
102 |
Which did I go with FreeNAS and OpenElec? Because I got sick and tired |
103 |
of dealing with gentoo on what is essentially a single-purpose |
104 |
appliance. I want the NAS and media front end to work like a DVD player |
105 |
- switch on, wait 10 seconds max, be good to go. It must also update |
106 |
like a DSL router - upload a 70M single image, reboot, be good to go. My |
107 |
notebook is Gentoo because it does 100s of things and it must work *my* |
108 |
way, the media server does 1 thing and it must JustWorkRight always |
109 |
|
110 |
|
111 |
-- |
112 |
Alan McKinnon |
113 |
alan.mckinnon@×××××.com |