1 |
On 2/27/20 4:49 PM, Rich Freeman wrote: |
2 |
> On Thu, Feb 27, 2020 at 4:25 PM james <garftd@×××××××.net> wrote: |
3 |
>> |
4 |
>> Yea, I was not clear. I'd run the mail-server, on a 'cluster' (4 or |
5 |
>> more), not an individual pi-board unless it was beef up, processor and |
6 |
>> ram wise. Gig E would also be on my list. |
7 |
>> |
8 |
> |
9 |
> Unless you have some niche need I wouldn't generally run servers on |
10 |
> Pis. The biggest issue with ARM is that all the cheap platforms are |
11 |
> starved for RAM, and RAM is one of the biggest issues when running |
12 |
> services. And of course the Pi in particular has IO issues (as do |
13 |
> many other cheap SBCs but this is less of an ARM issue). The RAM |
14 |
> issue isn't so many an ARM issue as a supply/demand thing - the only |
15 |
> people asking for 64GB ARM boards are big companies that are willing |
16 |
> to pay a lot for them. |
17 |
> |
18 |
> I do actually run a few services on Pis - DNS, DHCP, and a VPN |
19 |
> gateway. That's about it. These are fairly non-demanding tasks that |
20 |
> the hardware doesn't struggle with, and the data is almost entirely |
21 |
> static so an occasional backup makes any kind of recovery trivial. |
22 |
> The only reason I run these services on Pis is that they are fairly |
23 |
> fundamental to having a working network. Most of my services are |
24 |
> running in containers on a server, but I don't want to have to think |
25 |
> about taking a server down for maintenance and then literally every |
26 |
> IOT device in the house won't work. These particular services are |
27 |
> also basically dependency-free which means I can just boot them up and |
28 |
> they just do their jobs, while they remain a dependency for just about |
29 |
> everything else on the network. When you start running DHCP in a |
30 |
> container you have more complex dependency issues. |
31 |
> |
32 |
> A fairly cheap amd64 system can run a ton of services in containers |
33 |
> though, and it is way simpler to maintain that way. I still get quick |
34 |
> access to snapshots/etc, but now if I want to run a gentoo container |
35 |
> it is no big deal if 99% of the time it uses 25MB of RAM and 1% of one |
36 |
> core, but once a month it needs 4GB of RAM and 100% of 6 cores. As |
37 |
> long as I'm not doing an emerge -u world on half a dozen containers at |
38 |
> once it is no big deal at all. |
39 |
> |
40 |
> Now, if I needed some server in some niche application that needed to |
41 |
> be able to operate off of a car battery for a few days, then sure I'd |
42 |
> be looking at Pis and so on. |
43 |
|
44 |
|
45 |
Exactly. It's going to be a small RV, basically a 4x4 with a |
46 |
campershell. 2 Laptops with AMD64 and ram, the newest ones, are the |
47 |
powerhouses. One multicore with Radeon Graphics with a stand for 4x32" |
48 |
4K 120MHZ screens to be mounted on the 1/2 table in front of the bench |
49 |
seat (my new mobile office). I'm hoping to get gcc-9 (10?) happy with |
50 |
auto-compiling using the AMD graphics (radeon chipsets). And a plethora |
51 |
of small embedded boards for a wide variety of toy-interfaces..... |
52 |
|
53 |
|
54 |
Biggest problem? The arrival of the new roof mounted, 12VDC 21 SEER AC |
55 |
is delayed, due to that virus. Trying not to crank a genset, just solar, |
56 |
and fast-charge 12VDC battery banks; but we'll see how that goes in the |
57 |
Texas summer. I'm going to map out some 5G hot-spots and encourage folks |
58 |
in the areas to jump on a gentoo (derivative?) OS. The greater Dallas |
59 |
area is a hotbed for 5G testing and development. Austin is on fire with |
60 |
tons of new technologies too. Texas is pumping serious monies into |
61 |
everything 5G. It'll be an addon package for guys with tractors...... |
62 |
|
63 |
|
64 |
Making all of this fun and easy with Gentoo, should help grow our |
65 |
distro. The Texas Universities are moving to a new multi-homed private |
66 |
fiber network, where each link is 100G fiber based. So every campus in |
67 |
Texas, will soon be hotbeds for 5G R&D and play. Since the state of |
68 |
Texas has many 5G chip manufactures and many custom Rf shops, it's gonna |
69 |
be the worlds hotspot for 5G, imho. There's talk of Texas sharing this |
70 |
100G multi-route network with Oklahoma, Arkansas and Mississippi; a |
71 |
brilliant move imho. Gentoo could 'own' Texas, with just a wee bit of |
72 |
effort. IBM taking over CoreOS(new version of RedHat) is leaving a very |
73 |
foul taste in many circles..... |
74 |
|
75 |
|
76 |
5G + gentoo + embedded toys, is going to be FUN FUN FUN. |
77 |
|
78 |
|
79 |
Then I'll be off to other states, via a hacked out Redneck camper...... |
80 |
and too many microProcessors.... |
81 |
|
82 |
|
83 |
Thanks Rich, your insights and comments are always most welcome. |
84 |
|
85 |
|
86 |
James |