1 |
Frank Steinmetzger wrote: |
2 |
> Am Thu, Dec 08, 2022 at 05:30:18PM -0600 schrieb Dale: |
3 |
> |
4 |
>>> I use USB3 hard drives on Pis for my bulk storage because I care about |
5 |
>>> capacity far more than performance, and with a distributed filesystem |
6 |
>>> the performance is still good enough for what I'm doing. If I needed |
7 |
>>> block storage for containers/VMs/whatever then use a different |
8 |
>>> solution, but that gets expensive fast. |
9 |
>>> […] |
10 |
>> From my understanding, you are right about USB3 and GB ethernet being |
11 |
>> the big change. They also have more memory and faster CPUs but if you |
12 |
>> bottleneck the data with slow USB and ethernet with the old ones, who |
13 |
>> needs a fast CPU? I think they realized that the USB and ethernet had |
14 |
>> to improve. It got better from there. |
15 |
>> |
16 |
>> https://shop.allnetchina.cn/collections/sata-hat/products/dual-sata-hat-open-frame-for-raspberry-pi-4 |
17 |
>> |
18 |
>> I found the above. From my understanding, it allows a SATA drive to |
19 |
>> connect to either 2 or 4 bays. |
20 |
> Looking at the pics, it looks all very wibbly-wobbly. You will either have |
21 |
> the parts lying around open on a desk or you need to find a case for all |
22 |
> that stuff which adheres to no industry standard form factor. Pi accessories |
23 |
> are quite hard to come by, since they’re often sold out. |
24 |
|
25 |
They have a case for it too. Check this out. |
26 |
|
27 |
https://shop.allnetchina.cn/collections/sata-hat/products/quad-sata-kit-for-raspberry-pi-4-case-only |
28 |
|
29 |
|
30 |
> |
31 |
>> One thing I like about the Raspberry option, I can upgrade it later. I |
32 |
>> can simply take out the old, put in new, upgrade done. If I buy a |
33 |
>> prebuilt NAS, they pretty much are what they are if upgrading isn't a |
34 |
>> option. |
35 |
> If you just do storage, what do you need upgrades for, anyway? All it needs |
36 |
> to do is receive your data and write it to disk. And then return it later |
37 |
> when asked for. I don’t remember you mentioning running VMs or some such. |
38 |
> Any current commercial NAS has enough oomph for that, unless it’s a very |
39 |
> cheap ARM-based one. (Only the ecryption part remains to be solved with a |
40 |
> ready-made NAS.) |
41 |
|
42 |
Well, my pool of data keeps growing. I may need to add drives or |
43 |
something. Plus, every few years, I could upgrade the thing if I go the |
44 |
Raspberry Pi route. Keep it running fast and all that. ;-) |
45 |
|
46 |
|
47 |
>> I just wonder, could I use that board and just hook it to my USB port |
48 |
>> and a external power supply and skip the Raspberry Pi part? I'd bet not |
49 |
>> tho. ;-) |
50 |
> From a practical standpoint, what is the difference then to an HDD dock or a |
51 |
> simple USB-SATA-Adapter? Except that a dock is a “proper”, clean solution |
52 |
> with a nice case, a secure stand on your desk and no finnicky open SATA |
53 |
> cables that could cause disconnects during operation if you touch them the |
54 |
> wrong way. |
55 |
> |
56 |
> I know what it’s like to ponder all kinds of options, and it’s fun. But it |
57 |
> seems to me, you’re looking for a solution for a problem you’re still |
58 |
> looking for. |
59 |
> |
60 |
|
61 |
Given the size of one of the directories I have, it takes two drives, or |
62 |
soon will, and the use of LVM or something similar. I can't do that as |
63 |
it is now. I've even wondered if I hooked two eSATA drives up and gave |
64 |
both plenty of time to spin up if LVM would see them both and me be able |
65 |
to use two drives as one that way. Thing is, I don't know how LVM |
66 |
reacts if the two drives become available at separate times, maybe even |
67 |
many seconds or a minute or so apart. |
68 |
|
69 |
My problem is a growing directory. I admit, It's not increasing as fast |
70 |
as it was. When I was on DSL, it limited my speed a lot. With this new |
71 |
fiber internet, I can download huge amounts of data in a really short |
72 |
period of time. I can download it faster than I can verify it. I'm |
73 |
still checking things I downloaded over a month ago. I'm having fun |
74 |
doing it tho. ;-) |
75 |
|
76 |
I thought about breaking up that huge directory. Split it into two |
77 |
parts, the 'a' through 'l' and 'm' through 'z' thing. Then use two |
78 |
drives to back it up. Thing is, the external drive enclosures that I |
79 |
really like and trust, I can't buy anymore. They are Rosewill eSATA |
80 |
drive enclosures. It has a fan to keep things cool and a display on the |
81 |
front. They are really nice and rock solid. All the USB type drive |
82 |
enclosures I've tried caused all sorts of problems. I bricked a couple |
83 |
hard drives and eventually, the enclosures wouldn't work at all. The |
84 |
Rosewill enclosures are the most stable things I've ever seen. I wish I |
85 |
could find a few more of them, as spares if nothing else. |
86 |
|
87 |
Dale |
88 |
|
89 |
:-) :-) |