1 |
On Wed, Jul 19, 2017 at 7:26 PM, Dale <rdalek1967@×××××.com> wrote: |
2 |
> R0b0t1 wrote: |
3 |
>> On Wed, Jul 19, 2017 at 1:46 AM, Dale <rdalek1967@×××××.com> wrote: |
4 |
>>> Howdy, |
5 |
>>> |
6 |
>>> This isn't a Gentoo question but most everyone here used something |
7 |
>>> before Gentoo. I need a simple to upgrade distro for someone else. |
8 |
>>> |
9 |
>>> A friend of mine had windoze XP, which is dead to M$. She needed |
10 |
>>> something and buying a computer or new OS is not a option, even tho she |
11 |
>>> needs to upgrade that 10 or 12 year old thing she has. So, I put Mageia |
12 |
>>> on it a couple years ago, used to be Mandrake way back which is what I |
13 |
>>> started with. She has been doing updates every week or so since it is |
14 |
>>> GUI based and pretty easy. Tell it to update or just click the pop-up |
15 |
>>> when it tells you one is available and when it is done, reboot. Yea, |
16 |
>>> windowish I know. lol Anyway, she did a update and now she can't login |
17 |
>>> to KDE. I drove up, hour away, and tried to figure it out. It has |
18 |
>>> changed so much, I'm pretty clueless. It is NOT Gentoo by any means. I |
19 |
>>> renamed the user directory in case it was a config that the new update |
20 |
>>> was hanging on but nothing. It just won't let you login. Also reset |
21 |
>>> the password as well. Thing is, I installed ICEwm during the install |
22 |
>>> and it works. It logs in but the screen doesn't refresh like it |
23 |
>>> should. You close a app, it's closed but it doesn't refresh the screen |
24 |
>>> so it looks like it is still there. The whole thing is weird. Since I |
25 |
>>> couldn't figure out what the problem was, I tried upgrading to Mageia |
26 |
>>> 6. Figured if it was a software bug, maybe that would fix it. Nope. |
27 |
>>> So, she's using ICEwm for the moment but it is weird. |
28 |
>>> |
29 |
>>> What I'm looking for. Something that I can install fairly quickly from |
30 |
>>> a DVD. Rig is to old to boot from USB stick. Something with a GUI |
31 |
>>> update process that is fairly easy. Uses either KDE by default or is |
32 |
>>> easily installable, hopefully during install by default. The big one, |
33 |
>>> needs to be able to run on older hardware. Her rig is something like a |
34 |
>>> 2GHz single core CPU and around 2GBs of ram. The drives are SATA but |
35 |
>>> that's about the most advanced hardware it has. The video is a built in |
36 |
>>> Intel of some sort. Nothing fast or even fancy for that matter. Yes, |
37 |
>>> I'm keeping a eye out for a newer rig but it is what it is right now. |
38 |
>>> |
39 |
>>> I've used Gentoo for so long, I don't know what other distros offer |
40 |
>>> nowadays. I figure that there are several distros that are graphical |
41 |
>>> nowadays but also need good support for older hardware and easy update |
42 |
>>> process. Googling around isn't helping me much. If I find something I |
43 |
>>> like, no KDE. If I find KDE based and a GUI updater, something else |
44 |
>>> won't work. I figure asking those who have personal experience would be |
45 |
>>> best. :-) |
46 |
>>> |
47 |
>>> Thoughts? Suggestions?? |
48 |
>>> |
49 |
>> I second the suggestion to try Xubuntu, though you should also look at |
50 |
>> Lubuntu (which uses LXDE). Sticking to Ubuntu based distributions |
51 |
>> might be a good idea because there is a large userbase that has easy |
52 |
>> to search for answers to common problems. |
53 |
>> |
54 |
>> Plasma 5 might load her hardware too much. Is MATE unsuitable? You can |
55 |
>> also look for even lighter weight window managers and install them on |
56 |
>> top of the default desktop environment, but most of them target power |
57 |
>> users. |
58 |
>> |
59 |
>> https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/window_manager#List_of_window_managers |
60 |
>> |
61 |
>> R0b0t1. |
62 |
>> |
63 |
>> |
64 |
> |
65 |
> |
66 |
> I have a question or two on this. The reason I went with KDE, I use it |
67 |
> and it is closest to being windozeish. On occasion I read where some of |
68 |
> those other "lighter" desktops are 'feature rich' like KDE is. Example, |
69 |
> plug in a USB device and it pops up with a menu to select from a lot |
70 |
> like KDE does. Is LXDE or Mate like that? |
71 |
> |
72 |
|
73 |
MATE is probably the closest to a stereotypical Windows setup and |
74 |
looks better; LXDE should be technically sufficient but it's possible |
75 |
to say it doesn't look very nice. I would actually expect more culture |
76 |
shock going from Windows to KDE than Windows to MATE. MATE and Gnome 2 |
77 |
are fairly close to Windows XP in design, granted some things are |
78 |
moved around. Gnome 3 is closer to Windows 8 and 8.1. Plasma 5 |
79 |
implements more of the things that one finds in Windows 10. |
80 |
|
81 |
(Notably those desktop environments came out *before* the respective |
82 |
Windows versions that share UI/UX design elements with them.) |
83 |
|
84 |
When you get to the low end of desktop environments or window mangers, |
85 |
they tend to clash with default window stylings and don't offer any |
86 |
window chrome. They were made by programmers with little or no |
87 |
background in graphic design. |
88 |
|
89 |
> The thing about her, she doesn't know a lot about puters but she doesn't |
90 |
> mind clicking around to find a way to get things to work. Example, she |
91 |
> plugged her phone in and figured out how to download pics and stuff. |
92 |
> Heck, I don't know how to do that myself. Then again, my phone is so |
93 |
> old, it may not can do that. It's a old Motorola Razr flip phone which |
94 |
> I maxed out on contacts in my address book a while back. I want it to |
95 |
> be easy for her but at the same time, she can figure things out. She |
96 |
> also knows that as long as she is a user, she can't hurt much. She |
97 |
> stays away from root except when doing updates. |
98 |
> |
99 |
|
100 |
Generally if the person can get over the fact the OS isn't Windows and |
101 |
they will have to poke around things will be fine. |
102 |
|
103 |
> The biggest thing, her rig is old. It's older than my older rig and |
104 |
> ancient compared to what I'm typing on now which is several years old |
105 |
> itself but has upgrade room. lol |
106 |
> |
107 |
> Thinking about installing some of these on my rig and just seeing what |
108 |
> it looks like. < thinking > |
109 |
> |
110 |
|
111 |
Testing out desktop environments and window managers is good fun, but |
112 |
it dries up fast. Time permitting you might want to give your friend a |
113 |
live demo of a few different window managers (probably from one of |
114 |
your computers). Unfortunately my experience with old hardware |
115 |
suggests she will have problems running anything but MATE or LXDE. |
116 |
|
117 |
|
118 |
On Wed, Jul 19, 2017 at 7:46 PM, Rich Freeman <rich0@g.o> wrote: |
119 |
> On Wed, Jul 19, 2017 at 5:26 PM, Dale <rdalek1967@×××××.com> wrote: |
120 |
>> [...] |
121 |
> |
122 |
> To some degree I'd think Mate would offer this kind of experience. |
123 |
> Lightweight options like lxde or xfce are probably going to fall |
124 |
> short. Full Gnome or KDE are are probably as close as you're going to |
125 |
> get to a Windows-like environment. |
126 |
> |
127 |
|
128 |
I have seen complaints that LXDE or XFCE (and less commonly Mate or |
129 |
Gnome 2) is insufficient. It is my guess that the person actually |
130 |
thinks their window styling is ugly and noticeably different from |
131 |
Windows. Granted that's a perfectly valid reason not to use them, but |
132 |
even LXDE offers things like automatically mounted external storage. |
133 |
|
134 |
> Nobody seems to be mentioning full Ubuntu - assuming it performs well |
135 |
> it should of course be considered as an option as well. I'm all for |
136 |
> Xubuntu but it might not be the best fit depending. |
137 |
> |
138 |
|
139 |
Modern Linux development has left legacy machines behind. I had issues |
140 |
running stock Ubuntu, and even Xubuntu, on a computer less than 12 |
141 |
years old. |
142 |
|
143 |
R0b0t1. |