Gentoo Archives: gentoo-dev

From: Alexander Berntsen <bernalex@g.o>
To: gentoo-dev@l.g.o
Subject: Re: [gentoo-dev] Gentoo-hosted code review
Date: Mon, 02 Nov 2015 11:09:00
Message-Id: 5637443D.9070902@gentoo.org
In Reply to: [gentoo-dev] Gentoo-hosted code review by Michael Palimaka
1 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
2 Hash: SHA512
3
4 phabricator is very problematic in that it is a huge piece of PHP
5 software that is very difficult to change, and it's virtually
6 impossible to upstream your changes, unless they are simple bug fixes.
7
8 It is tailored to Facebook's workflow. Their workflow does not
9 coincide with most other people's workflow. It doesn't work for my
10 company, and I suspect it won't work for Gentoo either.
11
12 On the other hand it offers a lot of neat things, so experimenting
13 with it is good. Thanks for doing this work, Michael. Hopefully it
14 will lead somewhere.
15
16 As an alternative, that I have been meaning to look at, there's
17 critic[0]. It might be useful for someone to have a look at it.
18
19 [0] <https://critic-review.org/dashboard>
20 - --
21 Alexander
22 bernalex@g.o
23 https://secure.plaimi.net/~alexander
24 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
25 Version: GnuPG v2
26
27 iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJWN0Q8AAoJENQqWdRUGk8Bc34QANHVrS2kCfY+LCsyULj7wq0H
28 94oDyLkefB52RVnOVPA1/Bh35Yg44c38RY3sMRiWNzwcEu8SUdlO9N5cPLsaHEMR
29 Svngb/B5NaqIR4nt69OTXhC1NY8JzJSWbQeZ2OlNS/X9CW5DyTp8xYX08FzJWp6m
30 tj4+S6aTPNDoL16I07yMs3ArDJmnPBjoPZXyI8tOSiQSYPUIwGnm5KlmX9x24eQN
31 7byzVVW6WheXRwkiyppuchblFXHg7KwjWWuXa73zjPgJB18eix2UNVaaTnKdI60F
32 076Izhz3jcA3QhZJIqniAZSI4+ZXBJ3YJY0NS3sJ2wIcLm07LHgqpOb0N7mFMSWm
33 TI2dMB9ukY0KubdWbkkmkAIEFaUCI4SVQxMOZTn7prx1tqcv4lpZDTDDLqWV/nwa
34 KCt9UcdZiuhvqwWE/CEaTog/vZLOysuGvBZApf8PXnvfvXPANjVAUAKWnKtQE/K+
35 Uxxt2UlZfjgvFoGWSWalYzFgIKTt1ErCsV8EzLUvZb62f4BZAXVktyFbnXyGVKI8
36 cQKTyGKZa3mNjRr+G0WjaaDjLs6Ey4bHl4M7JBotuMD06cojsRc39iBouyHhVV4R
37 VKa/D/ePYVDYkH+CtZjIoRa5bdjwKRWpWxXmIZvQmmiH6lBGo39/QnT0zHgsxa7w
38 p2Ny4I7wCM/8zWfqRPx+
39 =6NcA
40 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Replies

Subject Author
[gentoo-dev] Re: Gentoo-hosted code review Michael Palimaka <kensington@g.o>