1 |
First of all, kudos to Curtis and team. This is definitely a step up from |
2 |
last time I checked. While I don't always agree with what's done, I do very |
3 |
much appreciate and respect all the effort that's put in. |
4 |
|
5 |
Here goes the comments... I'm just going to add to the discussion rather |
6 |
than starting from the beginning. |
7 |
|
8 |
> Usability and navigation needs work. Think in terms of end user.. |
9 |
> Someone may not land on the home page.. At which point he |
10 |
> will have to navigate to where he/she needs to get as quickly |
11 |
> as possible. With click-through patterns (If you can get the |
12 |
> data) see where people are going and make that most |
13 |
> accessible.. Navigation should be fairly site standard and |
14 |
> potentially even show a hierarchy of where they are in the |
15 |
> site. (ie Home > Solutions > etc) Do we have this data? Is |
16 |
> now the time to do a structure change to allow for faster digging? |
17 |
|
18 |
I've been stressing these points since day one, finally someone gets it! If |
19 |
we don't enhance the underlying design of the site (i.e. the "substance") in |
20 |
order to remedy some of the problems with the old design, the redesign would |
21 |
more appropriately be called a "face lift." I don't know what actually goes |
22 |
under the hood with all the xml etc., but to me, as it appears, it's simply |
23 |
a face lift. The functionality hasn't changed one bit. Navigation is still |
24 |
a nightmare. On a site as complex as Gentoo's, users -- especially those |
25 |
new to Gentoo (who also happens to be those who are critical to the growth |
26 |
of Gentoo) -- will be easily lost. They will have a hard time finding the |
27 |
information which they seek to make their decision to use Gentoo or to make |
28 |
their Gentoo experience successful. |
29 |
|
30 |
In hindsight, I realized that the project didn't have (I couldn't find) a |
31 |
clearly defined strategy (What is it trying to do? To achieve? And why? |
32 |
What's the ultimate goal?) and corresponding sets of concrete and achievable |
33 |
objectives that feeds into the strategy to make it work. |
34 |
|
35 |
When I started the project, I aimed for 3 things 1) to make a solid |
36 |
impression on visitors of the site in order to convey the values and |
37 |
benefits of Gentoo, i.e. in order to gain new users, 2) to make the site a |
38 |
pleasure to browse (for existing and new users), and 3) to make information |
39 |
easy to access. Graphics and eye-candy (if you will) along with |
40 |
strategically placed (and clearly/easily identified) critical "Gentoo |
41 |
elements" helps to achieve 1). 2) and 3) relates to usability (how |
42 |
efficiently and effectively a user can do what they want to do), navigation |
43 |
(how easily can a user move through the structure of the site, not simply |
44 |
linearly as non-linear navigation is what makes moving quick), and "flow" |
45 |
(how intuitive and logical is the structure of the site and the information |
46 |
presented). |
47 |
|
48 |
Now it seems that these goals were too ambitious given our limited |
49 |
resources. However, we seem to be taking baby steps toward them, which is a |
50 |
good thing. |
51 |
|
52 |
> I've looked at the preview images for the winning contest.. |
53 |
> Is it too late to consider moving the three navigation boxes |
54 |
> to the left hand side and or keeping some of the left hand |
55 |
> navigation there.. |
56 |
|
57 |
Christopher, we've gone a ways since the preview images. A newer proof of |
58 |
concept / early prototype is here: http://www.aaronshi.com/gentoo/ |
59 |
|
60 |
> While we are an open source project there are still two very |
61 |
> desirable actions we want users to do.. |
62 |
> |
63 |
> 1) Download and try the software (Rename mirrors and get |
64 |
> gentoo to Download and make it very clear where users can |
65 |
> download from.) |
66 |
> 2) Make a donation (this should also be something more than a |
67 |
> standard PayPal button, but still discrete and site blended.) |
68 |
|
69 |
Agree with both objectives in the general sense. The donation objective |
70 |
never occurred to me, but it's a very neat idea since Gentoo is an NPO and |
71 |
suffice to say it doesn't sit on a mountain of cash so any extra funding is |
72 |
probably a positive thing. |
73 |
|
74 |
Quirks: |
75 |
- The front page news area seems really out of character (the lines, the |
76 |
styles, the indentation, etc. seems "off") |
77 |
- General spacing is messed up, i.e. lots of white space where there |
78 |
shouldn't be |
79 |
- Table borders don't quite fit into the theme |
80 |
- I thought the 3 jump pads are only supposed to appear on the front page? |
81 |
|
82 |
I don't think the bolding or whiter shade is necessary for my credits at the |
83 |
bottom. Thanks for thought though, but such credits should be as |
84 |
unobtrusive as possible so that users can better focus their attention |
85 |
elsewhere on what's important. It's probably better left as before -- |
86 |
unbold, dark shade of purple (see bottom of |
87 |
http://www.aaronshi.com/gentoo/guidepage.html). |
88 |
|
89 |
|
90 |
Aaron |
91 |
|
92 |
|
93 |
|
94 |
|
95 |
-- |
96 |
www-redesign@g.o mailing list |