1 |
2009/6/3 Piotr Jaroszyński <peper@g.o>: |
2 |
> 2009/6/2 Doug Goldstein <cardoe@g.o>: |
3 |
>> All, |
4 |
>> |
5 |
>> The current council meetings have gotten completely out of hand for |
6 |
>> weeks meetings have become nothing more then a continuation of the |
7 |
>> senseless bicker-fest that have become the e-mail threads on GLEP54, |
8 |
>> GLEP55, and EAPI-3 without any real progress or sense coming of them. |
9 |
>> It's taken me a little bit to step up and put a stop to it but I fully |
10 |
>> intend on putting a stop to it. The point of the council meetings is |
11 |
>> to bring up a topic and decide on its merits whether it should be |
12 |
>> brought into the Gentoo Project or not. I quote from the first line of |
13 |
>> the Gentoo Council website: |
14 |
> |
15 |
> I am the author of both mentioned GLEPs but I don't feel too guilty |
16 |
> about that. Council had every opportunity to decide upon them , one |
17 |
> way or another, or state clearly that they don't like this or that. |
18 |
> Instead, there has been a pointless discussion each time (4c comes to |
19 |
> mind here). Imho, council should be less afraid to make difficult |
20 |
> decisions. |
21 |
|
22 |
I happen to completely agree here. I can't count how many times I've |
23 |
pushed the council to simply vote on what's presented to the council |
24 |
and not try to create 6 months of debate and mailing list threads to |
25 |
try and appease every single person so that the GLEP will get passed, |
26 |
even if its not even related to the original GLEP 6 months later. |
27 |
|
28 |
But again, this goes back to the situation where the wrong people are |
29 |
running for the council for wrong reasons and other developers are |
30 |
electing those people for the wrong reasons. The amount of time spent |
31 |
debating something over the pretty look and not over technical merits |
32 |
creates terrible signal-to-noise ratios (where I consider the pretty |
33 |
debates as noise and the technical merits as signal). |
34 |
|
35 |
I urge everyone running for the council to really look inward and see |
36 |
WHY you're running. I urge everyone voting to look at the candidates |
37 |
before you and decide if they will do their jobs as the technical |
38 |
overlords of the Gentoo Project or bog themselves down in the noise. |
39 |
|
40 |
-- |
41 |
Doug Goldstein |